Amazon.com Customer Reviews
All LP Versions - Review written on June 22, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
There isn't much I can add to the other reviews in terms of this legendary group, inducted into the R&R Hall Of Fame in 1998. However, for those who are conditioned by the term "greatest hits" meaning those renditions that made it to the Billboard Pop Hot 100, be advised that these are all LP cuts.
For example, while the hit single version of Witchy Woman, which came out on Asylum 11008 in 1972 (# 9) is 3:53 in length, the version presented here is 4:14. Likewise with Lyin' Eyes, a # 2 in 1975 on Asylum 45279 at 3:58, whereas the cut here is 6:24.
For those seeking the single versions, and even those not overly concerned with such things, I would still recommended looking around for recent compilations which present upwards of 20 to 25 cuts, complete with informative liner notes and discographies. This has nothing in either regard.
Also how, exactly, does Desperado fit within the term "greatest hits" - LP cut or not? That not only never made any singles charts, it wasn't even the B-side to one of their charted singles.
A Fairly True "Greatest" - Review written on February 01, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
I wasn't the biggest Eagles fan, for sure, and I'm normally not fond of "Greatest Hits" compilation albums.
However, this album gets a strong 4 stars from this reviewer, primarily because the music IS really good. Of course, if you hate the Eagles, you can't stand a country music influence, or if you're just biased by the fact that you've simply heard these songs too many times over the past 30-some years, then you will surely give this album a poor rating.
People continue to buy this compilation because it truly represents the best of this band's first four releases, with one possible exception. Go ahead and listen to The Eagles (1972), Desperado (1973), On the Border (1974), and One of These Nights (1975); IF you like The Eagles' music, I predict with almost-absolute certainty that the listening enjoyment from playing this one CD will FAR EXCEED what you will get out of any of those single albums, each of which contains some very non-memorable tracks.
I happen to have a fondness for their sophomore release "Desperado," with its old-west, outlaw theme. However, it's NOT like I can point to any particular songs on that album and claim that they were unjustly excluded from the Greatest Hits (the closest candidates might be "Outlaw Man" and "Bitter Creek").
So what's the exception I alluded to above? In my opinion, the title track from "On the Border" was the ONE best "pre-Hotel" Eagles song that was for some reason not included on this album. It could have easily replaced what I feel was the SAPPIEST song on the Greatest Hits, that being "Best of My Love," which even this reviewer has a hard time listening to today.
One more interesting note (forgive me if this has been brought up in one of the many reviews which preceded mine): back in the early 70's FM radio was just being born, and these Eagles songs predominantly became "hits" AFTER (and because of) the release of this Greatest Hits album! In other words, these songs were NOT popular AM radio hits when this album came out. This is very much unlike MOST greatest/best-of releases, which I tend to avoid because they are for the most part comprised of a bands most POPULAR tunes (instead of their truly BEST songs).
Thus, these songs were not chosen for this album because of their popularity, which sets THIS Greatest Hits compilation apart from most others. These songs WERE the best Eagles songs from that era, and that is why this album continues to sell so well. If you like (liked) The Eagles, this is the only pre-Hotel album you really need to own.
Eagles- Their Greatest Hits - Review written on December 03, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
ESSENTIAL ALBUM!!! This album, along with Michael Jackson's Thriller, flip-flop as the number one selling album of all-time. There are ten timeless classics here from the pre-Joe Walsh era of the Eagles. All but one of these songs charted & the one that didn't should have. There are a few omissions but they're minor ones.
The album opens with "Take It Easy" which peaked at #12, Jackson Browne was a co-writer on this song. Next is "Witchy Woman" with it's American Indian sounding intro, it peaked at #9. "Lyin' Eyes" was one of the first songs from a pop artist that crossed over into the country charts. It went to #3 on Adult Contemporary, #8 Country & #2 Pop Singles. "Already Gone", one of their best rock songs went to #32. "Desperado" didn't chart but I consider it to be in my 50 greatest songs ever. "One of These Nights" was a #1 hit. "Tequila Sunrise" only made it to #64 but I consider it to be one of their best songs. "Take It to the Limit" was written & sung by bassist Randy Meisner, it went to #4 Adult Contemporary & #4 Pop Singles. "Peaceful Easy Feeling" went to #22. The final song on the album, "The Best of My Love" has a world-weary sounding vocal by Don Henley, another great song by the Eagles; it went to #1Pop singles & #1 Adult Contemporary.
This is an outstanding compilation, good reasons for it being one of the two best selling albums of all-time.
fine collection of early classic hits by The Eagles - Review written on August 14, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
The Eagles gave us some of the best music to come out of 1970s America. Their tunes were creative, romantic and passionate--often all at the same time. They sang of love and dared to perform their numbers with all their feelings exposed. This CD gives us a remarkably fine sampling of just how good The Eagles really were between the years 1971 and 1975.
The track set begins with the country flavored rock tune entitled "Take It Easy." The song explores the value of keeping your cool even when things go wrong. The band rocks hard but not so hard that your ears ache; and the vocals leave nothing to be desired. Awesome tune! "Take It Easy" has great guitar work and harmonizing, too.
"Lyin' Eyes" became an instant classic when The Eagles released it--and rightly so. This song about the pain of a manipulative young woman has a strong beat with just a few country twangs on the guitar to enhance the beauty of this ballad. When the band members sing in unison their harmonizing will impress you. Moreover, the lyrics have a great deal of meaning--"Lyin' Eyes" became a wonderful rock tune for good reason!
"Already Gone" rocks hard with some great guitar playing; I love this song about a guy who leaves his woman before she could leave him! Revenge is sweet, folks! "Desperado" shifts gears markedly; this deeply sad, meaningful ballad explores the angst a man feels when his one true love just won't settle down with him. "Desperado" is one of the best songs The Eagles ever performed; I predict that you will like "Desperado" very, very much.
"Take It To The Limit" has an especially romantic quality to it; the men sing of how they really want to share their lives with their respective one true loves. They deliver "Take It To The Limit" with panache and all their hearts and souls. They truly give blood for this ballad; and it shows as you listen to it.
"Peaceful Easy Feeling" sports that mix of country with rock again; the singer explores his love for his soul mate. The guitars work wonders for "Peaceful Easy Feeling;" and the drums shine, too. Last--but not least--comes "Best Of My Love," a moving ballad about a love between man and woman that just isn't quite right. "Best Of My Love" makes a strong ending for this album. Great!
The impressive artwork replicates the jacket from the record album; and we get the song credits in the liner notes.
The Eagles dominating the music scene in the 1970s and they earned every bit of praise they ever received. I highly recommend this CD for fans of classic rock and classic pop vocals that have a rock and roll sound with that country twist.
Whole world in a few words ... - Review written on October 25, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
Just a word or two about "Lyin' Eyes". I wish the full version were sung every time, including on my old vinyl disc and the double-CD Farewell Tour concert version. Those who pan it as 'fragmentary' and 'long-winded' need their ears syringing. The sheer narrative economy is exemplary and stunning.* The first four lines give the story, background and 'feel' of the girl's whole life to date(you wonder what sort of job she was in, to open doors with just a smile; cold-calling for a party-plan sales business - or is it simply a generalised metaphor? ... you Want to Know). Even the shadowy figure of the ancient husband gives us an instant snapshot into his mind, brings him to life just enough . The narrative 'voice' is superb, too; reminds me of (another underestimated work)Kubrick's movie 'Barry Lyndon' - detached, objective, judging but never condemning or come to that justifying, just short of sympathetic, just telling it the way it is - about all concerned. Plus (back to The Eagles, God love 'em) the simple, beautiful music. In short, up there with the best of the folk ballads, like Mattie Groves and Barbara Allen. Thanks to a band that reminds you what it's like to be human!
*Another example - from a song that's become a bit of a joke, but is still great of its genre, is 'Lucille'. Imagine the content of the first few lines of that on film: the establishing shots, exterior ... interior ... Takes 1, 2, 3 etc. - all in around ten seconds of lyric.
4. I am over 13, by over 50 years, and a retired Eng. Lit. teacher currently writing a book on Shakespeare. So there.
Mellow Country-Rock - Review written on July 26, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
The Eagles have a reputation that groups them the greats of rock and country-rock. This reputation comes in spite of the fact that the Eagles released but seven albums in their two incarnations, six of which they released between 1972 and 1979. Their last album was "Hell Freezes Over," an orphan released in 1994.
The first four Eagles albums provided enough material for the first of six collections, titled "Their Greatest Hits." This album covers the Eagles from 1971 to 1975, the pre-Joe Walsh years. In general, their music during these years had a country flavor, flavored with rock influences. I consider the Eagles of these first four albums to be one of the first true country-rock bands. I also think that Don Henley and Glen Frey brought to this genre a style and talent that reminds me of the Beatles in their middle years.
This album captures quite a range. "Desperado" is probably the most overtly country in style. "Witchy Woman" has a rhythm that seems to me to be influenced by Native American music. Other songs move further away from country, but still show their country influences; examples are "Already Gone" and "Peaceful Easy Feeling."
You can also detect elements of the Eagles that would be more strongly manifested in "Hotel California" and "The Long Run." "Witchy Woman" has a strong electric guitar lead. "Already Gone" also has a dominant lead guitar, which at that time was more associated with rock. The latter song could have gone on "The Long Run," an album that moved the Eagles away from country flavored music.
I think the Eagles are highly regarded because of the quality of the songs created by the group and because of the influence they had on other country-rock groups. They showed others that country and rock could be successfully married and that people would buy such music when it was performed well. They also showed others that the same group could create a song that would be considered rock, and on the same record have a song with strong country influences. Along with a number of other groups in the 60s and 70s, the Eagles were groundbreaking in their own way.
It's easy to look back on this music and put it down because 30 years later it is no longer fresh, new, or original. There have been hundreds of imitators of the Eagles. However, the Eagles were one of the first, and in many ways, were the first. Those who came later imitated the Eagles and performed similar music so many times that after a while the impact of the Eagles appears to have been diluted. In truth, that impact occurred when these songs were released, and are part of the continuing evolution of music. Try to put yourself back in the early 70s when this music was released. It was great then; fresh, innovative, and young. The jungle beat of disco, techno-pop, the discordant chords of Nine Inch Nails were all yet to be, and the Beatles had only broken up recently. I will always remember this music for how unique it was when released.
This particular version of the Eagles' "Greatest Hits" is an import. There are several variations of this album available, so I recommend you research the various versions and their price and then select the version that meets your needs.
If you like what you hear on the radio of the Eagles then you will enjoy this CD. I prefer the albums to this collection, because I think the albums have more music equal to the music on this CD, but this collection is a good introduction to the early Eagles. Enjoy!
So how'd this get to be the best-selling album in American History? - Review written on May 09, 2006
Rating: 1 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful, 21 did not.
Turns out everyone who bought a copy of this album made a major mistake. Thankfully, that mistake can be fixed. All you gotta do is return your copy to whatever record story you bought it at and ask for your money back.
Now what about the music? Well, I gave it one star, so that should be a sign it sucks. Any album with Witchy Woman, Desperado, Peaceful Easy Feeling, Lyin' Eyes, Take it To the Limit, Best of My Love and One of These Nights would be worth one star already, but they lose even more points by ruining a great Jackson Browne song (Take It Easy). Skip this.
Easy to listen to and showa the eagles at their best - Review written on April 14, 2006
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
Before the 1976 release of "Hotel California," one of the groups most beloved songs and albums, the Eagles released a buch of pretty mediocre albumw, having only one or two really nice songs. This compilation takes all the neccessary songs--all hits!--and puts it on one disc. While other artists on their greatest hits albums will put fan favorites and such, this album is only putting on the hits, so your bound to recognize everything even if you don't listen to the Eagles. This album will let any new fan see why the eagles dominated the charts and it goes by rather quickly and easliy so you won't get board. Fans may not like this as much because it doesn't contain Hotel california, New Kid in Town, Life in the Fast lane, pretty maids all in a row and heartache tonight--all release on a second volume of the series--but this album is still good. i'd recommend buying both the albums together as Amazon offers.
Mellow Country-Rock - Review written on January 22, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
The Eagles have a reputation that would seem to put them into the same class as the greats of rock. This reputation comes in spite of the fact that the Eagles released but seven albums in their two incarnations, six of which they released between 1972 and 1979. The last album was "Hell Freezes Over," an orphan released in 1994.
The first four Eagles albums provided enough material for the first of six collections, titled "Their Greatest Hits." This album covers the Eagles from 1971 to 1975, the pre-Joe Walsh years. In general, their music during these years had a country flavor, but was balanced with rock influences. I consider the Eagles of these first four albums to be one of the first true country-rock bands. I also think that Don Henley and Glen Frey brought to this genre a style and talent that reminds me of the Beatles in their middle years.
This album captures quite a range. "Desperado" is probably the most overtly country in styling. "Witchy Woman" has a rhythm that seems to me to be influenced by Native American music, and thus is not true country, but has enough country elements to be considered either country or pop/rock. Other songs move further away from country, but still show their country influences, such as "Already Gone" and "Peaceful Easy Feeling."
While the country influence is there, you can also detect elements of the Eagles that they would more strongly manifest in "Hotel California" and "The Long Run." "Witchy Woman" has a strong electric guitar lead. "Already Gone" also has a dominant lead guitar, which at that time was more associated with rock. The latter song could have gone on "The Long Run," an album that moved the Eagles away from a country flavor.
I think the Eagles are highly regarded because of the quality of the songs created by the group, and perhaps because of the influence they had on other country-rock groups. They showed others that country and rock could be successfully married and that people would buy such music when it was performed well. They also showed others that the same group could create a song that would be considered rock, and on the same record have a song with strong country influences. Along with a number of other groups in the 60s and 70s, the Eagles were groundbreaking in their own way.
It's easy to look back on this music and put it down because 30 years later it is no longer fresh, new, or original. There have been hundreds of imitators of the Eagles. However, the Eagles were one of the first, and in many ways, were the first. Those who came later imitated the Eagles and performed similar music so many times that after a while the impact of the Eagles appears to have been diluted. In truth, that impact occurred when these songs were released, and are part of the continuing evolution of music. Try to put yourself back in the early 70s when this music was released. It was great then; fresh, innovative, and young. The jungle beat of disco, techno-pop, the discordant chords of Nine Inch Nails were all yet to be, and the Beatles had only broken up recently. I will always remember this music for how unique it was when released.
This particular version of the Eagles' "Greatest Hits" is an imported remaster of the original. On my poor sound system I have a hard time hearing the difference between this version and the original. There are several variations of this album available, so I recommend you research the various versions and their price and then select the version that meets your needs.
If you like what you hear on the radio of the Eagles then you will enjoy this CD. I prefer the albums to this collection, because I think the albums have more music equal to the music on this CD, but this collection is a good introduction to the early Eagles. Enjoy!
This is top of my list favorite album. - Review written on January 11, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
There's a reason why this album has sold over 14 million, cause it is the best greatest hit album out there, still is, period. Every song on this album is a gem from Take It Easy all the way to Best of My Love. From ballads to straight out rock and roll, to R.B. to country, all elements are here. My all time favorite since the day it was concieved is One Of These Nights, all time favorite. Used to have this on vinyl and cassette, now I have it on CD, time to convert people, go out and get this greatest hit package, well worth it.
say what you will - Review written on September 19, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review not to be helpful.
i refuse to hide the fact that yes i do like all kinds of music and the eagles are definitely one of those bands from the seventies that are a great band.this,part one of the original greatest hits albums is perfect from start to finish.this is the way 'greatest hits' albums should be,even if it is only 10 songs,at least it doesn't have alternate versions or new tracks,like everyone seems to do nowadays.did i mention how i hate when bands do that? anyway,this is an album of beautiful melodies that should not be forgotten.yes they should have stopped for good when henley said,"when hell freezes over",nor would i ever see one of their money-making last tour finales. but i refuse to let the great songs that they put down upon wax go to waste.if you've only heard about the eagles and want to check them out do yourself a favor and start here,than pick up the next greatest hits album,vol.2.