Amazon.com Customer Reviews
This Soundtrack & Neil Diamond ROCK!!!! - Review written on January 09, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
This was one of the most successful movie soundtracks in that it remained on Billboard's top 100 albums for nearly 3 years. It produced 3 #1 songs, Love on the Rocks, America, and Hello Again, a personal favorite as it's my wedding song. This is not Diamond's only musical appearance in films. He also wrote the famous song "Be" for the film "Jonathan Livingston Seagull."
Neil Diamond has legions of fans and it is well-deserved recognition. The CD is excellent in regards to Diamond's work, but the quality of the CD is rough in some places where you can hear an annoying hiss sound when the volume is pumped up and for his rock songs you certainly want to do that, but with ballads on high volume you can here the hiss more. Other than that, this soundtrack remains ageless as does most of Diamond's music.
I wrote a review for the film that covers how I feel about that work so you can check there to read that, but for brevity's sake here I'll just recommend that you buy or rent the film. It is so much better than the critics who ripped into it both then and now. Of course, being a Diamond fan helps, but Lucie Arnez and Laurence Olivier also make the film very watchable.
This is my 1st introduction to Neil Diamond - Review written on April 04, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 2 did not.
I became a fan to Neil Diamond instantly since picking up the soundtrack to the movie "The Jazz Singer" which I have on VHS (since 1997). That's how it all laid out. That's when I became known as a trumpet player since right after watching the movie and listening to the soundtrack. I briefly wore out the LP quite a bit but not much but I day I'll have it out on CD 2 go. Yep as to say this one of my all-time favorite movies and soundtracks,'Nuff said. 'Cuz a lot of ya'll Neil fans can't go wrong on this. This is out for all the nay-sayers/haters who disagrees with this album, nor the movie, I think you shouldn't be proud if u would've rated it higher or else just give it just 1 shot by downloading or getting it a used music store or something. And for agreers/reviewers that agree with the soundtrack and movie nor the soundtrack instead of the movie nor the movie instead of the soundtrack or whatever. I agree with you 100%. I don't care whethere they like it or not. Either hate it or love it like 50 Cent and the Game say on the hit single "Hate It or Love It". This is familar to those who are fans to Miles Davis, Charlie Parker, John Coltrane, Marvin Gaye, Quincy Jones, Ray Charles, the Big Bands, and all of that stuff, y'feel me? This is a must for those that listen to gospel instead of secular music or else listen to secular/mainstream music nor listen to jazz, are involved in the gospel choir and band (which I'm in), are in the music business (gospel, Christian or secular) or whatever. This is definitely the movie you must-have in your collection if you love Neil Diamond or else never even love jazz or never even know him in general, etc. I guarantee you 100% you won't be dissappointed. I luv every song that's on the album and it's still good. Period.
If you ask me . . . - Review written on April 02, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
7 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
"America' should have won the Oscar for the best song of 1980! Actually the year 1980 was a great one for pop music in the movies, unlike the stark crops of recent years. The official nominees included "Fame" and "Out There On My Own," both from FAME, "On the Road Again" by Willie Nelson, and "9 to 5" by Dolly Parton. There was also one dud, "People Alone," from THE COMPETITION which hasn't stood the test of time.
If you ask me, "America" should have been nominated and could have won, even under such stiff competition. And I know some of you will say the same of "Hello Again" and "Love on the Rocks" two of Neil's softer tunes.
However, XANADU fans are still smarting over the total lack of Oscar recognition for the many great tracks in the movie--"Suddenly," "Magic," "Xanadu," "All Over the World" and "Suspended in Time." As for which soundtrack LP is the better bargain, I call it a draw!
PS, by the way, the award went to FAME which isn't a disgrace.
Listen to Neil Diamond's soundtrack and skip the film - Review written on April 27, 2004
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
The decision to make a modern version of Al Jolson's "Jazz Singer" in 1980 is one of the more dubious ideas to come out of Hollywood. Putting singer Neil Diamond in the Jolson role opposite Laurence Olivier as his cantor father and Lucy Arnaz as the woman he loves had only one sure upside in that Diamond also did the music for the film. If your choice is between watching the film or listening to the soundtrack, then listen to the soundtrack.
Diamond was inspired by the immigrant element of the story to honor the national melting pot in the opening song "America," along with one of his better ballads from that part of his career "Hello Again." The songs also play to Diamond's strength in that several of them would be done "live" in the context of the film, and anyone who has listened to "Hot August Night" or any other concert album by Diamond knows he is a lot better live than he is in the studio. In retrospect that is clearly the point in Diamond's career where the hard rock and gospel influences went away and he began a soft rock/pop artist where songs like "Love on the Rocks" and "Summerlove" became the norm. His early songs are arguably his best, but it was not until his 1976 album "Beautiful Noise" that Diamond ever had an album go platinum.
To his credit Diamond does come up with songs that meet the narrative needs of the film, not that this is a reason to watch the movie, so do not accuse me of advocating you do that. There is no reason for you to see that "You Baby" is part of an awkward homage, for lack of a better word, to Jolson in black face. Also worked into the mix are some traditional Jewish songs, "Adon Olom" and "Kol Nidre/My Name Is Yussel," and Diamond makes an earnest attempt to do them right. The resulting mix might be uneven, but there are enough solid songs here to make this an above average Neil Diamond album.
3 good songs and the rest is BAD!!!! - Review written on April 21, 2004
Rating: 2 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 10 did not.
Starting with September Morn, all of his CDs have been very uneven and this is one of the worst. This has a couple of good songs on it (you know what they are) but the rest is REALLY BAD!!! I wish they would put out Greatest Hits Vol. 3 with all of his great songs since September Morn that aren't on Vol. 2 including That Kind, The Sun Ain't Gonna Shine Anymore, On The Way To The Sky, Right By You, The Drifter, First You Have to Say You Love Me, Front Page Story, Heartlight, In Ensanada, Turn Around, You Make It Feel Like Christmas, Sleep With Me Tonight, The Man You Need, Story of My Life, It Should Have Been Me, (I'll See You On The Radio) Laura, Me Beside You, Best Years of Our Lives, This Time, If I Couldn't See You Again, If There Were No Dreams, Don't Turn Around, Hooked On The Memory of You and a couple from Tennesse Moon and Three Chord Opera. Now that would be an AWESOME CD and you wouldn't have to waste your hard-earned money on awful CDs like this with only 3 or 4 good songs!!!!
Terrible Movie.. Decent Album - Review written on June 28, 2002
Rating: 2 out of 5
5 customers found this review not to be helpful.
This semi decent soundtrack is good as long as you haven't seen the movie... otherwise the schlock of the movie will make this CD of work a bitter pill to swallow, and your thoughts will be filled with terrible, terrible acting by Lucy Arnaz and Lawrence Olivier. I would suggest buying another Neil Diamond CD made before this one. The Diamond CDs only get worse as the years go on, and the Jazz Singer Soundtrack is the last listenable thing made by Neil Diamond. "America", "Love on the Rocks", "Songs of Life" and "Summerlove" are pretty good tunes. Those tunes make the disc worth owning for a hardcore fan.. However, "You Baby", "Hey Louise", "Acapulco", "On The Robert E Lee" and "Jerusalem" are utter garbage. "Amazed and Confused" is unlistenable. "Adon Olom" and "Kol Nidre/My Name Is Yussel" are just things put on the album to take up space. I would suggest Stones, Moods, or Greatest Hits over this..they are money well spent.. the Jazz Singer is not.
One of Neil's BEST...and very underrated! - Review written on January 02, 2002
Rating: 5 out of 5
Lets face it, Neil is not the best actor in the world - but when he sings, it is PURE MAGIC. This 'soundtrack' album holds some of his best work ever, including the classic 'Love on the rocks' and 'America', amidst at least a half a dozen others. I have to hold a candle to this man, who is still drawing in major crowds at age 60+...and has not had a real major top 10 CD in years!
This is the inspiration that is Neil Diamond...and sticking to the subject of this CD, he truly shines in all ways on this one. There are some rockers, fun stuff, blues, totally mellow and the classical ND commercial stuff - and all done with soul and passion. Unlike a lot of his work that surrounded this one, this really had a lot of Neil's heart and soul, and not a lot of some studio producer telling him 'what was next'.
What can I say - I thought the movie was great (not a classic mind you), and I admired Neil for giving the old Hollywood thing a go (don't think he has done it since!) - and the bottom line is that despite the shortcomings of this movie, we as fans got to enjoy some of his finest work ever!
A great injustice was done to Neil refgarding this album. - Review written on October 13, 2001
Rating: 5 out of 5
12 customers found this review helpful.
For some reason, Neil Diamonds's peers have not held him in the same high esteem his fans have. The fans are rigght and his peers are wrong. This CD has three top ten tunes in it, "America," "Hello Again," and "Love on the Rocks." All are great songs and all were hits 20 years ago. There were additional great rockers like "You Baby Baby" on this CD. Inexplicably the academy did not even so much as nominate the movie "The Jazz Singer" for the best score nor did any of the three mega hits get a nomination for best song. This was an unconscionable dump on a great star and songwriter. He deserved an Oscar and did not even get a nomination!
I recommend both the cd and a video of the movie. The cd has great studio versions of the songs whereas the movie has some great, energetic live performances, particularly of "You Baby," and "Amazed and Confused." This cd is abslolutely classic and as of the writing of this review, "America" is particularly uplifting so soon after the terrorist attack on New York & the Pentagon. Indeed, the night before this review was written, I saw Neil Diamond in concert at Madison Square Garden & he had the crowd on it's feet with "America." This is a cd that we as fans know is great regardless of what his peers may have thought. I hope in the future, some justice will be done and he will be inducted into the Rock n roll Hall of Fame.