If you're a Dylan fan, you'll enjoy this recording!
Recorded by Stephanie Sane
The older songs on this CD are great, but they do have a different sound from their originals; this may disappoint some fans, and I admit it took me a while to appreciate this version of "The Times They Are A-Changin,'" but the soul of the songs remain the same, no matter what kind of modernized or different interpretation Dylan decides to go with on a certain night. I love "Tombstone Blues," and it does start the CD out with a great kick. It's always nice to hear Dylan's "All Along the Watchtower," if for no other reason than to let people know the song didn't originate with Jimi Hendrix. "Rainy Day Women #12 & 35" has never been a favorite of mine, but this version is a enjoyable splash of fun in between a couple of slow, serious songs. "John Brown" is a significant track, dating back to the 1960s but never having been released. It truly reflects the anti-war feelings Dylan expressed so forcibly in his formative years. As great as the classic tracks are, the tremendous newer songs only build on the musical momentum and prove that Dylan's great songwriting days have yet to come to an end. I was a little surprised to see "Shooting Star" from the Oh Mercy album, but it sounds great and fits right in here. "Dignity" is another recent song that showcases Dylan's songwriting and singing.
Three songs particularly stand out on this CD for me. "Desolation Row" is a truly incredible, meaningful song that only Dylan could write and perform. Lasting more than eight minutes, I still always hate to hear it end. "Knockin' On Heaven's Door," a song which some listeners may not enjoy as much as I do, really starts building the momentum that reaches its crescendo with my favorite Dylan performance ever of his greatest song, "Like a Rolling Stone." Having wowed his audience for close to an hour, he is definitely "feeling it" when he gets to this trademark song. Its length is matched only by its powerful delivery, and I get the feeling listening to it that even Dylan is a little surprised at how great a show he is putting on. "With God On Our Side" is an interesting song with which to end the CD, but it reflects the heart and soul of music's greatest songwriter. Following on the heels of a rocking performance, it reminds listeners that the old Dylan so many have loved for decades is still there, even if his classic songs have been given a fresh overhaul.
This is by far my favorite Dylan CD. Having a rather small audience so close to the musicians makes this live performance a true personal triumph, and the sense of intimacy between Dylan and his fans is powerful and palpable. Dylan has never seemed happier or sounded better than he does here.
"Tombstone Blues" is a great opener. It gets the crowd energized, and is one of the great Bob songs you wouldn't know unless you bought the album Highway 61. My only complaint is that he cut out 2 verses, one of which had the great line "The sun's not yellow, it's chicken."
"Shooting Star" is a memorable, fairly obscure Dylan song.
On "All Along the Watchtower" Dylan rushes the ends to the verses but somehow it works. He surprises us with his quick delivery but it remains meaningful.
"The Times they are a-Changin" is barely recongnizable until Dylan belts out the first line. Dylan's band is great on this one, never losing track of their place despite Bob's playing around with the lyrics. Still, you find this tune stuck in your head afterwards the way it is performed here, as opposed to the famous original.
"John Brown" is Dylan's previously unreleased track. Hard to get through the brisk mumbles in some places (luckily the lyrics are included) but in the end it's an emotional anti-war piece that ranks up with his best.
"Rainy Day Women" here seems like Dylan just wants to get it over with, but the crowd sure loves it. I liked it as well.
"Desolation Row" is one of Dylan's best performances on the whole CD. Dylan sounds like he really wanted to play it, and it shows.
"Dignity" is also a part of "Greatest Hits 3" but otherwise unreleased. An upbeat number sandwiched between slow ballads.
"Knockin on Heaven's Door" is one track I've heard too many times, whether by Dylan or by other artists. Still, Dylan keeps it short here with only 2 verses, and he manages to switch the words around a little.
"Like a Rolling Stone" is drawn out to near 9 minutes on this performance, but it is one of my favorites on the whole CD. The crowd sure is into it, cheering at multiple places during the song. Dylan mumbles a few early lines, but really gets into it at the end.
"With God on Our Side" is one of Dylan's early protest songs. A welcome, surprising inclusion on this package. Dylan's band is great here; they amazingly manage to precisely follow Dylan's unpredictable beginnings and endings to verses. This inclusion seems like one Dylan himself really was eager to play, which makes it all the more memorable.
This is hard to do. There are very few successful live recordings which do this. Lou Reed succedded to do that in his 1983 live in Italy record (although his career was 'only' 20 years old at the time), but failed in 'Perfect Night', where the new (er) stuff works well, but with few exceptions the older stuff doesn't. David Bowie's Live in the BBC concert fails miserably in the first half of the concert, but hits the bull's eye in the second half.
Bob Dylan, however, doesn't even try in this record.
Out of thee 11 songs, all but 3 were written in the 1960s, and one of the three songs is "Knockin' on Heaven's Door". this makes this a wonderful show for the people who left Dylan at woodstock ( yeah I know he wasn't there), but it feels a little like a nostalgy show for everyone else.
Some of the Oldies work wonderfully. Tombstone Blues, All Along The Watchtower, John Brown and of course, Like A rolling Stone, are brilliant, but others are just OK, and "Knockin' on Heaven's Door" has to go. The new songs, are great, especially Dignity, which is one of Dylan's best songs.
Overall, this is a strong record, filled with good songs by one of America's top songwriters. It's Dylan in top form - I'd just would have prefered a little more of the new and the exciting, and less reliance on songs 30 years past.
"Tombstone Blues" comes off with a crispness and a clarity that you don't get from Highway 61 (of course, thirty years of sound technology and practice makes a big difference)and "Dignity" was quite a find, aurally and musically, for more recent Dylan converts like myself. The rollicking sound of both of these songs is well balanced by the soulfulness of "Desolation Row" and "Knockin' on Heaven's Door." As far as ballads go, "Desolation Row" is to my ears one of Dylan's strongest live efforts and along with "Dignity," my favorite song on the album. And of course if anyone doubts Dylan's ability to lay right into our collective social consciousness, listen to "John Brown."
Dylan's voice certainly isn't what it used to be, but as anyone who has seen him perform lately well knows, he has more than compensated for it with his entrenchment as a rocker and as an entertainer. This album does a masterful job of capturing Dylan as both and it has all of the qualities you look for in a live album but don't often find: great sound, good rhythm and a Bob Dylan staple, poignant lyrics. If you're going to go on a roadtrip, this is definitely an album to bring!
Firstly, this album is simply full of great music and playing. From the opening bars of "Tombstone Blues" to the furious guitar punishing through "Rainy Day Woman #12 & 35" the musicians Dylan is working with here are clearly enjoying and pushing themselves.
And the interpretations! Songs which you will have considered perfect suddenly become EVEN BETTER on this album. "Love Minus Zero" has aged along with its author, and is presented as a giddyingly yet subtle haunt sound. "Shooting Star" is sung with so much emotion just listening to it becomes terrifying, as if Dylan or we will fall off its waves of sound at any moment. One or two of the songs performed are not enhanced by changes in Dylan's voice and performing style, but most become remarkable new treasures.
Although "MTV Unplugged" is probably more likely to impress those already appreciative of the Dylan project (in other words you'll like it more if you're a fan),it must be the most intense and committed album of the 'Unplugged' series. At once relaxed, fun and thoughtful, this is a brilliantly inventive, lyrically explosive and just plain great album