Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Big band, big chorus, big sound. - Review written on December 10, 2005
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
A different sort of Christmas album, Harry Connick's CD features the big band sound, strong drums throughout, large choruses in many songs--and Harry Connick. With toe-tapping rhythms and a casual, relaxed attitude prevailing, Connick presents many swingy versions of traditional songs and a number of quiet, soft ballads, accompanied by strings and chorales. Subtlety is not part of the pattern here--the music is, for the most part, bold, celebratory, and full of spirit--with the drums setting the beat and emphasizing the rhythms. The romance of the ballads is emphasized by violins and female choruses.
Throughout the album, Connick sets the pattern of the songs in the first stanza, retaining that pattern throughout, restraining himself from offering improvisations or variations, which would be difficult, if not impossible, with his large orchestra and choral ensembles.
"When My Heart Finds Christmas" begins as a romantic song introduced by strings, and builds to a crescendo at the end, to the accompaniment of insistent drums. In "It Must Have Been Old Santa," upbeat, loud, and full of swing, Connick showcases the piano, with the drums sometimes competing with it. "The Little Drummer Boy" carries a big drum, and the treatment is louder and more assertive than usual.
"Ave Maria" begins as a solo piano, a pleasant change from the elaborate treatments of previous songs, with Connick singing at the midpoint, but Latin is not his "native language," and the passion one associates with this traditional music is missing in this track. "I Pray on Christmas," however, is a hand-clapping gospel song, a rousing performance, stirring for the listener. "What Are You Doing New Year's" offers wonderful sax variations, the only song on the CD in which jazz variations take place.
If you are a fan of big band music and large choruses, Connick's album is highly appealing--fun, relaxed, and filled with the power of strong drumbeats. Connick is one of the players here, less a soloist and more of a director. n Mary Whipple
Merry Christmas! - Review written on October 22, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 7 did not.
The world was first intorduced to Mr Connick in 1993's Hope Floats. Being a virtually unknown Slovakian actor in the early 90s was no easy task. After many failed attempts at building an acting career, Connick decided to debut his musical skills in 1997 to the world with a Christmas album. Certainly an odd subject matter for a debut album, but it sure paid off!
From his originals, which include It Must Have Been Ol Santa, to Pray On Christmas, to more traditional fare, Oh Holy Night, Silent Night, I Heard The Bells On Christmas Day, Connick's ability as a vocalist really shine forth with the light of the season. Accompanied by a brilliant Pianist, Connick wins big!
A New Classic - Review written on November 17, 2004
Rating: 4 out of 5
With its cozy cover photo and charming sentiment, from the very first notes, When My Heart Finds Christmas sparkles with the classic charm of Dean Martin holiday affair, with mostly successful results. Connick opts for a largely unconventional lineup instead of an album full of the same tunes on everybody else's holiday CDs; interestingly enough, most of the lesser-known songs fly high while a number of the standards fall flat.
The opening track, a sprightly arrangement of "Sleigh Ride" that gets things moving nicely, and "Let it Snow! Let it Snow! Let it Snow!" crackles with insinuating joy, but "Rudolph" shows the dangers of utilizing a children's chorus, whose screechy exuberance mars an otherwise fantastic arrangement. "What Are You Doing New Year's Eve?" is nice enough, but it's a bit drab, especially for the last track. The very slow, dramatic "What Child is This?" may be a drag for some, and a tedious march arrangement of "Little Drummer Boy" quickly becomes grating.
Proving that not all marches are stodgy, however, "Parade of the Wooden Soldiers" is a smashing success among the less popular numbers, a high-kicking, kid-friendly confection. The Rat Pack throwback is most evident in the tight cocktail swing of "Christmas Dreaming," a Sinatra cover filled with winking cheer. The disc's crown jewel is the gorgeous rendition of "Ave Maria." Tender, delicate, unpretentious and oozingly slow, this is the one where you can really hear Connick pouring his whole heart in. It begins with a solo piano statement that would be more than enough by itself...but when Connick's haunting tenor comes in, trembling with emotion, its plaintive beauty surrounds you like a blessing straight from Heaven. A true joy, and worth the price of the whole CD.
Never one to rest simply on the work of others (as displayed in the series of photos accompanying liner notes, which show Connick chopping down a pine tree and dragging it home), Connick wrote four of the tunes himself. Of the two ballads, the title song comes off like a cheesy '60s ballad, but "The Blessed Dawn of Christmas Day" teems with reverent beauty. The faster numbers really deliver. The funky, festive "(It Must've Been Ol') Santa Claus" chugs with the zest of New Orleans, and you're absolutely dead if it doesn't bring a smile to your face. "I Pray on Christmas" shouts like a swingin' holiday revival, complete with call-and-response verses and a delicious piano solo. These two tracks are immensely joyful and deserve to become classics.
I think of When My Heart Finds Christmas like a holiday party thrown by a good friend. I love most of the people there, but some of my favorite guests are in a mood I don't care for, and some I just plain don't like, but I avoid them without complaint because the ones I enjoy are so great. I was *not* keen on this CD and its offbeat selection the first several times I listened, but I kept it because I adored three or four tracks. For some, this one's an acquired taste that's worth the effort; for those who do appreciate it, it gets better every year.
Harry at his Best - Review written on November 27, 2003
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
Track 1- Sleigh Ride- This is a great boisterous Christmas Classic, wonderful to jam to, and it is Jazzy in all the right places.
Track 2- A wonderful Christmas Ballard, sure to become a Christmas Classic for years to come.
Track 3- It Must've been ol' Santa Claus- Great jazzed version. Harry really belts out a good one here.
Track 4- The blessed dawn of Christmas Day- this song starts at slow, but Harry and the Big band, really blow it out at the end.
Track 5- Let it Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow!- WOW.. this is one of the best songs on the CD. It is so jazzed up, it is almost unrecognizable, but in a good glitzy way. The trumpets and saxophones, and all of the other big banders are at their best in this traditional hit. Harry sings his heart out with this one.
Track 6- The Little Drummer Boy- Great jazzed up version of a classic. Harry oozes talent on this one.
Track 7-Ava Maria- Oh the big band turns it out, for this complicated song. Harry is truly wonderful, there is one portion of the song, where the pianist solo is long, and when Harry comes back on vocals, he seems to be off a little bit.
Track 8- Parade of the Wooden Soldiers- great song. Once again Harry at his best.
Track 9- What Child is This- Oh the Big Band nearly blows me away on this one, it is truly a jazzed up version of a traditional classic.
Track 10-Christmas Dreaming- Great once again
Track 11- I pray on Christmas- a wonderful soulful Ballad, you can tell Harry was belting this one out from the heart. He put everything into it, and it should be a classic for many years to come.
Track 12-Rudoplh the Red-Nosed Reindeer- This is by far the best song on the CD. Harry takes a little kiddy Christmas traditional song, and turns it into a knee-slapping jazzed up version. The saxophonist is unbelievably grand and on key in this one, as well as the trumpeter and the whole BIG BAND. This is the first track you should listen to!!!
Track 13- O Holy Night- this is an ok version, it takes Harry a few verses to heat up on this one, but by the end, his true talents shines on.
Track 14- What are you doing New Year's Eve- A great ballad.
Why does the Christmas season have to be so short... - Review written on December 16, 2002
Rating: 5 out of 5
8 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
...as my husband has limited me to playing this between Thanksgiving and Christmas. This a truly wonderful Christmas album, as well as just being a great Harry Connick, Jr. cd.
There is a delightful mix of serious and silly songs, jazzy piano pieces and rollicking traditional songs and gospel-inspired songs and inspirational classics.
My favorites include It Must've Been Ol' Santa Claus, which tends to lead to dancing around the living room, O Holy Night which is heart-breakingly beautiful, the Little Drummer Boy (one of the only versions of this song that I really like), and What Are You Doing New Year's Eve, a wistful song which is the perfect ending to the cd. There really isn't a bad song on this CD.
If you like Harry Connick Jr, you will love this cd. And buy the soundtrack to When Harry Met Sally, which also contains a lot of holiday songs.
Terrific '40's big band sound. - Review written on December 15, 2002
Rating: 4 out of 5
7 customers found this review helpful.
Indeed, it's the big band sound which is the high point of this CD. From "Sleigh Ride" on, we're treated to the orchestral and choral arrangements so prevalent during the '40's. And this works for most of the cuts, including the strong originals presented here.
However, it does fail on the two most spiritual offerings, Schubert's "Ave Maria" and "O Holy Night". The former starts with a beautiful piano accompaniment, but Harry's voice just doesn't deliver "Ave Maria" well, nor does it work on "O Holy Night".
The rest of the album is great, especially for those who appreciate the old big band sound.
Always heavy in my holiday rotation - Review written on November 23, 2002
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 1 did not.
This disc has been heavy in my holiday rotation since its release. It has a great balance of tempos, and emotions. There are songs for the adults, and songs for the kids. "(It Must Have Been Ol') Santa Claus" is a great, fun, kid song. He respects the classics, but doesn't just copy the originals. He puts his wonderful touch to each song on the disc. Your grandparents won't complain when you put this one in, even if they aren't familiar with his works yet. He's so talented, that I really wouldn't have expected less from him, and he didn't disappoint with this offering.