Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Wonderful Movie, Crappy conversion to DVD - Review written on March 12, 2008
Rating: 3 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
I read the book and I loved it. Then I heard there was a movie about this, so I did some research and found the movie here at amazon. Reading other reviews, it was clear that the conversion to DVD was poorly done.
Well, the reviews are right. The movie is stunning, the story is beautiful, the photography is spectacular, the Soundtrack great, and the sound... Well, the sound is what took two stars away from my review.
Paramount should be ashamed of letting such a wonderful movie, where the soundtrack is basically half of everything, being release with no work at all at the sound quality. Zero, zero. The sound is MONO, and looks like somebody took an old voice recorder into the movie theater hidden in his pocket and recorded the whole thing.
I think this movie deserved a little more time and money dedicated to create a better package.
But still, the movie is worth it. I will complain at Paramount's site about this.
Needs more Neil, fewer birds - Review written on January 24, 2008
Rating: 2 out of 5
2 customers found this review not to be helpful.
This was Neil's first project for Columbia Records, following up his glorious "Moods" album on the MCA label, the one that opens with what would become his signature tune, "Song Sung Blue," and closes out with several songs that seem to hint he was already in "Jonathan Livingston Seagull" mode: "Walk On Water," "Theme," "Prelude in E Major" and "Morningside." Having just listened again to the JLS soundtrack for the umpteenth time, and then having watched the movie for the first time, I would suggest that any ND fans out there who, like me, went decades without seeing JLS should continue avoiding that movie at all costs, and give another listen to "Moods" again.
The main problem with the movie is that Neil ran out of songs about halfway through the film, at which point either there's no sound at all for many long minutes at a time (I exaggerate slightly -- there's the occasional sound of ocean waves crashing into shore), or you get to hear James Franciscus' voiceover as Jonathan. Now, Franciscus was a fine actor in his day, in projects as diverse as "Beneath the Planet of the Apes" and the underrated TV show "Longstreet," but his was not the voice of JLS. Neil should've written another half-dozen songs and they could've had a better movie just with the seagulls flying around and letting Neil narrate/sing the whole thing, kind of like "Tommy" but as a bird opera.
Instead, we get one really good song on the soundtrack, "Be," which you'll notice appears four times out of 12 tracks, so clearly Neil recognized he had a dearth of good material so he had to stretch out the good stuff as far as it would go. "Dear Father" is okay, but feels like it's half-finished, and it appears three times. "Skybird" starts out great, but also feels unfinished, and it appears twice on the soundtrack. See the pattern here? The rest of the songs aren't really even songs -- just snippets of songs. If you want to listen to a well-thought-out spiritual odyssey, then listen to "The African Trilogy" songs on the "Taproot Manuscript" album. Much better stuff.
Great movie, poor conversion to DVD - Review written on October 09, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful.
This review assumes that you are already familiar with the movie and are interested in what the DVD has to offer. If you want a review of the movie itself, see the other reviews; people either love it or hate it. I love it.
That being said, this is one of the poorer conversions to DVD that I have seen (the worst being my "Red Dawn" DVD, but don't get me started). Colors are not vibrant, blacks are not that deep, and about the only positive thing I have to say about the video quality is that it has been cleaned up to remove artificts (unlike "Red Dawn," grr). So, while the video is clean, it is nothing spectacular.
Audio has got to be the biggest disappointment; it has been remastered in Dolby Digital mono. That's right, mono. Not DTS, not 5.1, not even stereo, but mono. Adding insult to injury is the quality of the audio. Sure, there is no hiss or sound of scratches, but the audio is flat. Specifially, the music. Dialogue in the movie does not really need much, and it would have been better in stereo, and better yet in 5.1. But the music, one of the best components of the movie, is disappointing.
Thus music has no range, no depth, no life. My sub rarely kicked in. Neil Diamond's voice sounded muffled, as did the music itself. What should have been a great musical experience turned into a pale shadow of what might have been.
On top of all this, there are no extra features or frills. This is pretty much a straight burn of the video to DVD. The menu screen is a still pic with just three choices (play, audio setup, and scene selection). That's it.
Don't get me wrong, I still love the movie. I was disappointed years ago when I heard there were no plans to release JLS to DVD. This DVD is definitely better than a VHS alternative, so I am very glad Paramount released it to DVD. It is just disappointing that they did not spend some extra money to improve the video quality, and nearly a crime they did not remaster the audio better (and in 5.1).
Spectacular! - Review written on October 06, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
The scenery and photography here are spectacular, to say the least. I saw the movie when it first came out, and I have owned Neil Diamond's soundtrack album for years and have loved it, have known it note by note. I play some of the songs. I have since earned a degree in music and am familiar with music from all genres, but this remains a favorite, a constant. It's nice again to see how the music relates to the visual aspects of the film. This film isn't for everyone. People who like fast action, gunfights, car chases, and such will find this film boring. However, if you can accept it for what it is, it's a beautiful experience all around. I don't mind the talking birds--remember "Babe," the talking pig? I like watching Jonathan working out his struggles in learning how to fly better, faster, higher and seeing him succeed. For me, it's a very uplifting movie. I only received it the other night, and I have already watched it five times. You might think of it too has an extended music video with all those gorgeous scenes--think wildlife, nature photography--together with the lush, mostly orchestral music. It's a different kind of movie. I know it has been ridiculed by many people for many reasons, but to some of us, it remains special. Like it says on the box, it is a movie with stunning beauty.
Beautiful pictures, decent songs, and then the seagulls start "talking" - Review written on October 05, 2007
Rating: 3 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful, 4 did not.
I know that I read the book, "Jonathan Livingston Seagull" by Richard Bach and that my girl friend in high school gave me the soundtrack album, so I remembered the handful of Neil Diamond songs that show up in this movie, but I remembered nothing about the plot. I mean, yes, I knew there was this seagull and that there was some sort of simplistic life lesson to be learned here, but it was not until the seagull started talking about flying really fast that I remembered that was the catalyst for the title character's quest, exile, and ultimate redemption. I also remembered that the message was not why I went to go see this movie when it came out in 1973.
I still think this is a beautiful film, which deservedly received an Oscar nomination for Jack Couffer's cinematography because basically this film was IMAX before IMAX was around. The beginning is gorgeous and it takes you a moment to remember that you want to pay attention to the seagull and not the scenery. This proves to be the fatal flaw in this film. Because once we start focusing on the seagulls we focus on one in particular, and he has a story that has to be communicated through voiceovers. I recognize the voice of Philip Ahn as Chang, because I watched "Kung Fu" when it was on, but I never would have guessed that was James Franciscus doing the voice of Jonathan. The problem is that every time we get to the voice-overs in this movie, I start to get bored, even though I know the dialogue is necessary to advance the plot of the film (this sentiment is extend to Dimaond's work, where I like the music way more than the lyrics). It is just that suddenly I seem to remember a joke about the book, namely that it was a best seller because there were more people than you would have thought who had never read "The Little Engine That Could," and I have to wonder about people with so little in their lives that the book could have meant so much.
To be fair, the movie should not be confused with the book, if for no other reason that Bach sued Columbia over the changes they made to his story when they filmed it. Then again, I have no idea what those changes might be or how the vision of the author has been corrupted by this adaptation. There are no DVD extras and there are six--count them, six--scenes to select. They are numbered (you guessed it) 1 through 6, and if you can look at the pictures above the numbers and figure out what part of the film it is, then you must really love this movie. I was going to round up on this one, just because the cinematography is as gorgeous as I remember, but when I saw the film was divided into six numbered scenes, I had to head in the other direction. This is one of those films that I have to think will interest only those people who saw it before and want to see it again, whether such an interest is restricted only to the beautiful photograph or to the whole "message" it has to offer.
Just life itself can touch you deeper. - Review written on June 13, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
"Lost...on a painted sky...you may find Him...if you may",I mean...How Neil Diamond made this? Where he flew to see this? From all the icons I've seen in my life - "A seagull flying high in the sky + the sound of BE" is one of the strongest. An absolutelly beautiful work, timeless, for all times, powerful as our own will, transparent, marvelous to the tears roll down for pure emotions. To me, this music put sound to the book. A book I read 15, 20, 30 times? I don't know. Every theme evokes part of JL Seagul's journey - "Lonely looking sky, lonely sky" - Provably one of the best spiritual go up music made in the western culture. The journey to awakening is lonely...now you can fly with this music as a companion and don't fasten your seatbelt.
A Truly Ethical Movie with Morals We Need To Teach Humans. - Review written on July 27, 2005
Rating: 4 out of 5
9 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
I remember seeing this in a theater in Nashville, Tennessee, with my two young sons, when it was first released -- so long ago, and yet the magnificient story and music are still the same. Now, my twelve-yr-old cat, Star, likes to look at the birds on the t.v. screen but is perplexed by their human voices.
The music was just great! Neil Diamond was simply marvelous back then providing the music for this and the remake of THE JAZZ SINGER. Both make me cry sometimes as they tug at the heart strings. Killing me softly with his song!
Hal Holbrook was good as the voice of the mean one, the elder who banned Jon from the flock for daring to be different, and later did the same to poor Fletcher, because of his crippled wing. When you get past the noise of the birds feeding on garbage, the story soars just as Jonathan Livingston Seagull at a fairly fast clip, on the wings of a prayer. The narration is perfectly done: both Jon L. and the angel Seagull who comes to take him to a better place.
He returns the favor to Fletcher and teaches him that he can fly with the best of them. The worst part was near the end of the movie when the baby bird is knocked into the rock cliff and dies. That made me sad initially, but I can understand the significance now that I am older. It's not easy being old, but it's much worse to die young.
Jonny will always be a bird after my heart. As a result of this movie, I feed the pigeons here in town and the few birds who returned after last year's bad treatment. I fed the geese at one place I lived out of town here and, as a result, had to move. We do have small flocks of seagulls near the malls and out west at that Walmart. We are far from any sea, but the Tennessee River can furnish them with carp and other dietary fish they may need. Just so they leave the catfish for me!