Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Essential! - Review written on May 02, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful, 5 did not.
The Temptations were one of Motowns hottest and most versatile acts. They began their career as The Primes, singing on street corners in the ghetto areas for blacks in Detroit with Diana Ross And The Supremes (then known as their sister group, The Primettes). After signing to Motown in 1961, they took a seperate road from The Supremes and before long, were pumping out to what would amount too, an endless river of classics.
In early 1964, the dynamic David Ruffin took over as lead vocalist of the group and immediatley gave them their own unique, identifiable sound, much in the way that Diana Ross had with The Supremes. Their first major hit would be produced by the genius, Smokey Robinson, who wrote and assembled the fantastic and highly infectious, The Way You Do The Things You Do, which featured a remarkable range of harmonies all blended fantastically well together which gelled neatly into the state-of-the-art soul production.
However catapulting them into wider recognition was their 1965 hit, My Girl, which soon became a chart-topper and one of their most distinguished classics. This was also one of Smokey Robinsons most lyrically and evocative compostions. With its sweeping strings and unforgetable vocal trade-offs on the chrous, this has easily become one of Motowns signature tunes.
They also conveyed their versatality on such lush, romantic ballads that steered narrowly into pop with such offerings as I Wish It Would Rain, Since I Lost My Baby and You're My Everything as well as enjoying a dynamic tour de force with Diana Ross and the Supremes on such fabulous cuts such as I'm Gonna Make You Love Me, which are all included on this superbly compiled collection.
They also made renowned classics such as the jamming, Get Ready and Ain't Too Proud To Beg. The alternating lead vocals between the forceful, aggressive delivery of David Ruffin and the sweet, sensual falsetto of Eddie Kendricks marked an interesting transistion in their work. David Ruffins voice mostly sounded seemingly angst ridden especially on the magnificent, (I Know) I'm Losing You.
Other than Smokey Robinson, a large portion of their work was produced by Norman Whitfield. What Whitfield encapsulated with his work with The Temptations was blending late 60's trends of Pop and Funk into this groups output, giving it a healthy balance and therefore making The Temoptations strong innovators with their music.
In 1968, David Ruffin was eventually fired and after an unsuccesful solo career, got caught up in a hazadous whirlwind of drugs and died in 1991. He was replaced by Dennis Edwards, another forceful and dynamic singer that certainly had all the credibility of David Ruffin as The Temptations continued to pump out hits until the early 70's.
Cloud Nine marked a turning point for The Temptations, becoming one of their own and indeed, Motowns landmark recordings. It introduced an injection of social consciousness into the lyrics and featured a startling psychedelic guirtar riffage amidst the complex musical arrangements.
The Temptations were clearly influenced by the Rock-Soul-Psychedelic phenomenon and much of their output from the late 60's to the early 70's, encapsulted this explosive range of styles on such fantastic recordings as Psychedelic Shack and the compelling masterpiece, Runaway Child, Running Wild.
They scored one of my most favourite classics in 1970 with the rip-roaring, Ball Of Confusion, which offered profound political statements and social commentary. Dennis Edwards voice is just explosive and gives startling ignition to the stark musical arrangements that is broken up by an effective harmonica interlude.
Finally in 1972 they scored their last major hit of their heyday with the compelling, Papa Was A Rolling Stone (another favourite of mine), a triumphant soul masterpiece with its compelling undertones of red hot, pulsating funk. After this their momentum sadly wore thin but this compilation highlights their upmost glory days and they remain significant influences in todays music culture.
GET READY!... - Review written on October 15, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
At last, a little truth in advertising! Here is truly the ultimate career spanning collection from the best and baddest soul group EVER, Motown or otherwise. The temptin' Temptations were blessed with a trio of powerhouse lead singers, from David Ruffin's pleading, sexy growl to Eddie Kendricks' otherwordly falsetto to Dennis Edwards' mighty macho screams; the payoff was the longest list of RNB and pop classics by anyone out there. Motown maestro Smokey Robinson provided them with an embarrassment of musically creamy, lyrically cunning masterpieces such as GET READY, THE WAY YOU DO THE THINGS YOU DO, DON'T LOOK BACK, and of course MY GIRL. Likewise, the incredible composing team of Norman Whitfield and Barrett (MONEY) Strong helped the Tempts score later smashes via earthier, frequently topical material (PAPA WAS A ROLLIN' STONE, BALL OF CONFUSION, and AIN'T TOO PROUD TO BEG). Though their lineup was constantly shaken by personal turmoil (four of the original quintet died tragic deaths), the Temptations were, to quote a hit for which there was apparently not enough room here, SUPERSTAR's of the highest magnitude, leaving behind a wellspring of timeless gems to prove it. RATING: FIVE TEMPTATION WALKS
The Temps! - Review written on August 14, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
The Temps are one of my favorite Motown bands, and this is a very strong collection from them. Just about every song is classic, and it contains minimal filler. The best material, in my mind, is from I Wish It Would Rain to my favorite Temps tune, Papa was a Rolling Stone. But the early stuff (My Girl, Get Ready, Ain't Too Proud to Beg, I'm Losing You) is also excellent. The last few songs, with the exception of Treat Her Like a Lady, are weak, as are All I Need, You're My Everything and Angel Doll. There is also a missing song: Runaway Child, Running Wild. Great song, I wonder why it wasn't included. But this is a great collection and is worth your money.
"And the band played on" Temptations Greatest Hits - Review written on April 06, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
The first couplet of the first song begins "You've got a smile so bright, you know you could've been a candle./ I'm holding you so tight, you know you could've been a handle."
Anyone who has heard of the Temptations knows those lines from their classic "The Way You Do the Things You Do." It is crisply sung, almost doo-wop. It never loses its poise or falls into cliche.
Most of these songs were hits. If the titles don't jar your memory, listen to the samples. Expect to know at least 10 of these.
A couple weak links are present in "Treat Her Like a Lady" and "Error of Our Ways." In these two songs, there's no funk, no soul, and no depth. Both are acceptable, as pop R&B, but are musically pallid when compared to "Papa Was a Rolling Stone" and "Ball of Confusion."
The liner notes provide a puffy history, and credits song-by-song. That's not why this is worth buying. It is the sheer cool class and sway of the Temptations greatest hits. A couple songs might be left off, but most are here.
I fully recommend "The Ultimate Collection" by the Temptations.
Anthony Trendl
editor, HungarianBookstore.com
Good sample of the soulful, tempting Temptations! - Review written on April 07, 2004
Rating: 5 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
This is a terrific compilation from probably the best Motown act ever! Yes, there are few errors here: songs like "Beauty Is Only Skin Deep", "I Could Never Love Another After Loving You", "Loneliness Made Me Realize It's You That I Need", and "Psychedelic Shack" are missing. I think I can understand why Motown did what they decided to do with this. The Temptations were a really special group, and their musical output was beyond vast, both with their hits and misses. A wide overview of this output was given and not just stuck to the same era. That's why songs like "Treat Her Like A Lady", which is from the '80s, and "Error Of Our Ways", from the '90s is on here.
I don't why an a capella version of "My Girl" is here, though. If the four songs mentioned above were on this disc, it would be perfect running at nearly 80 minutes. Things were done to preserve continuity. All in all, you can't resist the temptation of purchasing "The Temptations: Ultimate Collection."
It makes you cry...for the wrong reasons - Review written on March 18, 2004
Rating: 2 out of 5
15 customers found this review helpful, 4 did not.
For a serious Temptations fan (exempli gratia, ego) this is a pretty lousy and insufficient compilation. The pattern of lineups in this group can best compared to Lynard Skynard-there are so many flamin' line ups that it gets to the point where it's not the same group anymore; it's just the Temptations by name only. David Ruffin, Otis Williams, Melvin Franklin, all of them gone. If you ask me, the real Temptations died the early 1970s. In place of indispensable gems of their golden years (id est, the REAL Temptations) such as "Slow Down Heart", "Beauty Is Only Skin Deep", "Just Let Me Know", etc. this "ultimate collection" includes mediocre, (relatively terrible) latter cuts such as "Error of Our Ways". If you endeavor the enchanted staggering, and soul-moving work buy their studio albums prior to 1976 like "Meet The Temptations" and "Temptations Sing Smokey"; the earlier the better. They are more rare, but they are worth the purchase. Also, almost any other Temptations hits compilation is way better. I give this one an extra star for the beautiful closing track, the acapella of "My Girl". It makes me cry and reminds me:
RIP TEMPTATIONS 1961-1976
The Temps' new record's a gas - Review written on June 19, 2003
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
If you know where the title of this review comes from, then you will appreciate this collection and don't need me to tell you much about the Temptations. This is the best single-CD collection of their material. The only reason not to get it is that there is a 2-CD album "My Girl: Best Of Temptations" that is more complete, including two glaring omissions from this collection, "Beauty's Only Skin Deep" (unforgivable!) and "Runaway Child, Running Wild". It's true that this collection includes "Error of our Ways", a beautiful and important song from 1994, which is NOT included in the "My Girl" collection, but it hardly makes up for the missing "Beauty". Either way, you are getting a stirring, stunning collection from the best soul act ever, but my recommendation is to lay down the extra bucks and go with "My Girl".
One of the great Motown groups - Review written on March 01, 2003
Rating: 5 out of 5
57 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
This is not quite the ultimate Temptations collection, but it comes close. You could never fit all their great songs on one CD anyway, but the compilers were clearly determined to include some of their later recordings - the last three tracks on this CD. Angel doll, though recorded in 1967, was not one of their big hits - indeed, it was not even released at the time. The inclusion of these four tracks at the expense of real classics, including Beauty is only skin deep, devalues the title somewhat.
Despite the omissions, this is the best single-CD collection of Temptations music currently available and contains many familiar songs. It begins with The way you do the things you do. A big hit in America, it did not chart in Britain. I first came across the song via an excellent cover by Rita Coolidge, but the original version is impressive. Other classic sons here include My girl, Get ready, Ain't too proud to beg, I wish it would rain, Cloud nine, I can't get next to you, Ball of confusion, Just my imagination and Papa was a rolling stone.
Anybody seriously interested in sixties music in general and Motown in particular will enjoy the Temptations. Unless you want to go for a double-CD or a boxed set, this is the CD to choose.