Amazon.com Customer Reviews
It's not paranoia if they're really after you. - Review written on December 24, 2006
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
ENEMY OF THE STATE is flashy, big budget, adrenalin-pumping cinema as only director Tony Scott and producer Jerry Bruckheimer can concoct. It's raucously entertaining and most certainly a strident rallying film for the conspiracy theorists. Now I don't know just how accurate the movie is in terms of the technology depicted (I'd say fairly accurate) or of the dubious lengths to which our government will stoop to achieve its ends, but, certainly, the sincere and bravura acting of the high powered cast lends this over the top film an element of plausibility.
Several SPOILERS here: When a nature photographer (Jason Lee) accidentally tapes the cold-blooded murder of a high profile congressman, it sets off a chain of events which horrifyingly affects and endangers Washington, D.C. attorney Robert Dean (Will Smith). When a corrupt, high ranking agent of the National Security Agency comes to believe that Dean has in his possession evidence which will incriminate him, he and his henchmen turn Dean's universe instantly topsy turvy; as a result of their manipulations, Robert Dean is summarily fired from his law firm, framed in the newspaper, accused of having an affair with an ex-flame and current informant, and stripped of his finances. Even his cell phone stops functioning. He is bugged six ways from Sunday and is reduced to running for his life clad in his undies. It's hard work evading these determined people as Dean is easily pinpointed by the NSA's use of aerial surveillance and sundry tracking devices. But Dean receives unexpected aid from an enigmatic ex-intelligence agent (Gene Hackman, again acting with ferocity) as he tries desperately to stay one step ahead of his powerful, omnipresent pursuers and somehow salvage the remnants of his life.
You have to hand it to Scott and Bruckheimer, when they get together (DEJA VU, CRIMSON TIDE, TOP GUN), their enthusiasm knows no bounds. This rapidly paced hi-tech thriller/chase film takes Hitchcock's innocent man on the run premise and inserts its own brand of polished action sequences and well-executed stunts/fx. There's no questioning it's slickness. It's also enhanced by the solid performances of everyman Will Smith, the surly Gene Hackman, and the villainous Jon Voight. Regina King, Jamie Kennedy, Jack Black, and Lisa Bonet (still sexy) all contribute nicely in supporting roles.
ENEMY OF THE STATE is a cautionary fable which raises the issue of national security and of our government's constant need to gather intel for our own protection, but juxtaposed against that is the violation incurred to our civil rights, and, how, depending on the man, certain moral lines are easier to cross in pursuit of the big picture. As someone said, "Absolute power corrupts absolutely." This film would have us believe that, with the application of space satellite imagery, super dedicated cameras, various transmitters and taps, our government can now have access to our privacy at a moment's whim. The sobering thing here is that the frighteningly detailed surveillance technology shown in this film - which would make J. Edgar Hoover cream in his dress - is, no doubt, in existence and is probably in steady use - for our own good, of course. Sucks for us and the so-called American way of life. I'm sure, somewhere, George Orwell is saying, "See - I told you."
The Fresh Prince Has Been A Bad Boy - Review written on November 05, 2006
Rating: 4 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful.
It only took me 8 years, but I was finally inspired (by Will Smith recently filming "I Am Legend" right in my neighborhood) to see Enemy of the State. And it was a good 2 hours and 10 minutes of time well spent.
Will Smith is on a roll...has been on a big screen roll ever since Bad Boys (1995). It seems that he always plays the same character: confident, smart talking, tough, funny. But the redundancy works...every time. It worked in Enemy of the State too.
Like a lot of other Will Smith movies ("Independence Day", "Men in Black", "I, Robot", "Hitch"), Enemy of the State is a thoroughly entertaining movie that keeps you in your seat. It's got a great story with some great actors.
And post 9/11, the subject of government surveillance is even more on topic. Can anyone say, "The Patriot Act"?
Enemy of the State is classified as a thriller. A thriller is supposed to be exciting, full of suspense, intrigue and mystery. Enemy of the State does not disappoint.
A worthy rental.
Solid Action From Tony Scott & Jerry Bruckheimer In A Much Needed Double Dip, But Is This Truly Unrated? - Review written on May 22, 2006
Rating: 3 out of 5
34 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
MOVIE: Enemy of The State is another one of Jerry Bruckheimer's mid 90's action extravaganzas. He reunites with Tony Scott to bring us this action flick about government coverups and how technology is used to basically track every aspect of your life. The movie is about a lawyer who is unwillingly thrown into a wild cat and mouse chase. A congressman is murdered near a reservoir where research is done on migratory geese. So, unknowingly, the whole thing is caught on tape and ends up in the hands of a nerdy and young Jason Lee. He realizes what he has in his possession and during a foot chase he bumps into his old friend played by Will Smith and secretly drops the tape in his bag. Now Will Smith's character is thrown into a world of espionage without knowing why he is being hunted. He meets up with Brill, played by Gene Hackman, an ex NSA agent who ends up helping him. Hackman basically plays a reincarnation of his character in Coppola's The Conversation. The movie is directed at a fast pace by Tony Scott, and it's an overall entertaining action flick. I felt the movie tried to be smarter than it actually was and that the characters were very plain and boring.
ACTING: I didn't like Hackman in this role, but Will Smith brought some life into the movie. For people who haven't seen the movie in awhile you should check it out to recognize some young faces including Jack Black, Jake Busey, Jaimie Kennedy, Seth Green, and the of course the previously mentioned Jason Lee.
VIDEO: The great thing about the recent releases of Con Air, Crimson Tide, and Enemy Of The State are the new anamorphic transfers of the films. They are greatly appreciated and are so much better than the old ones. The quality of the transfer has not improved greatly in terms of picture quality, but there is a noticeable difference.
AUDIO: As for sound we get a very dull Dolby 5.1 mix. All the dialogue is usually center heavy, and rarely does action actually envelope you from the surround speakers. The track is the same from the old release, so it's not the best. There are some scenes with helicopters and some big explosions that utilize the surround speakers well, but overall it's a very dull mix.
SPECIAL FEATURES: The "making of" featurette was actually more extensive than I was expecting. They talk more about the gadgets used in the film versus the actual movie, but overall I found it to be interesting. All the interviews were done back during the making of the movie and it was a pretty extensive behind the scenes for what the movie is. One thing I found extremely interesting was that they talked about a scene where Will Smith is chased by cars in an underground tunnel in his bathrobe. In reality, the cars didn't fit into the tunnel so they had do take the cars apart and weld them back together in the tunnel. The entire scene was maybe a minute long! I just found it interesting that all that work was done for maybe a blip of action. Anyway, the next featurette is basically some on set footage. Overall the two featurettes do justice for what this movie is.
BOTTOM LINE: I got confused whether this was indeed an "extended" cut of the film or not. The cover you see on places like Amazon is not the cover that you actually get. The cover of the film is actually labeled "Special Edition", but the menu does indeed say "Unrated Extended Edition". So, I am thoroughly confused. I didn't notice anything noticeably new, and the running times listed are identical between the old disc and the new one. Still, the upgrade is worth it.
The Cure for the Evasive Number 2 - Review written on May 11, 2006
Rating: 1 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 13 did not.
The formula for any Will Smith movie is to have him say "Damn" every six line of his dialogue and give him really cute humor, no matter what the situation is. This movie was totally unbelievable, honestly. For instance, Big Willie Style running around Metro D.C. in the winter wearing only boxer shorts. Not to mention countless errors both in editing and directing. On to the plot, the entire American government is evil (it can happen), mind you are villains are Jon Voight, who I can swallow as a villain, but Jamie Kennedy, Jack Black, Barry Pepper, Jake Busey and Seth Green?! Is this an action movie or a poor man's Kids in the Hall? Gene Hackman is always good, but I don't even think Lex Luthor can help the Fresh Prince in this over price bucket of trash.
Hey we should all just get Jiggy with it!!
"You have something they want!" - Review written on March 21, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful.
When compared to MAN ON FIRE and DOMINO you have to understand that this is one of those movies where an average joe's life gets flipped upside down when he intercepts very politically, and potientially deadly, threatening materials. The minute we find ourselves plugged into this man's world we are introduced to several people who are keeping tabs on him 24 hours a day. They wait outside in trucks, bugging him, tapping him, questioning him, even picking up satiliete images to pin-point his exact location. It gives an all new meaning to the words "overactive paranoia." But, in DOMINO, it related the most becuase DOMINO, as well, was about someone normal who evoked a change in her boring life. This is the story of a man who didn't ask for his life to be changed. Whihc makes him the perfect everyday hero, in my humble opinion.
Enjoy!
A Pleasant Surprise - Review written on February 06, 2005
Rating: 4 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful.
Despite the fact that we both like Gene Hackman and Will Smith, my wife and I put off seeing this movie for along time, thinking that it was probably going to be just another run-of-the mill Jerry Bruckheimer action flick, all of which get to be a bit overblown and "samey" after awhile (IMO Crimson Tide, and the spoof, ConAir, are his best films)...but what would otherwise just have been another pretty good action/suspense film, took on an eerie resonance in the post 9/11 era--the legislation that the Jon Voigt character was willing to kill to get passed had more than a faint aroma of "The Patriot Act"-- and I'm surprised that more reviewers haven't mentioned that.
As far as the "lack of substance" that some reviewers mention, that is entirely subjective, and I do not agree with it. As far as reviewers who talk about this not being as good as 1974's The Conversation, get a clue that elements of this movie are conscious homages to that earlier (and IMO, badly dated, and overrated) movie--one of the things that's fun about Bruckheimer's movies is that they are full of homages to earlier suspense/action flicks, esp. those that influenced him. Also, folks, get a clue to the fact that the Will Smith character's "dumbness" and naivety, is part of the point of this movie: his ignorance of technology, and his over-reliance on other people for information, put him at the mercy of the "heavies" in this movie, and left him wide open to the crisis in which he found himself embroiled. As an aside, along the lines of the eerie resonance of this movie in the wake of 9/11, it gave my wife and I a bit of a chill down our spines when Gene Hackman's character revealed by "hacking" into the NSA computer that the Jon Voigt character's birthday was "9/11"--an eerie coincidence three years before 9/11/01.
ENJOYABLE FILM - BUT GO SPECIAL EDITION DVD OR BLU-RAY INSTEAD - Review written on December 01, 2004
Rating: 1 out of 5
16 customers found this review helpful, 4 did not.
UPDATE [6-Dec-2007]
This review pertains only to the original DVD release, which delivered a non-anamorphic letterboxed transfer, and not the current Special Edition DVD and Blu-ray titles, which deliver anamorphic and high-definition transfers, respectively. To summarize, I highly recommend the film but advocate bypassing the older DVD release for either the Special Edition DVD or Blu-ray packages.
ORIGINAL REVIEW
The star rating system unfortunately doesn't allow reviewers to assign separate at-a-glance ratings for content versus technical presentation. My abysmal lone star reflects only criticism of this disc's technical merit and not its content.
From a content perspective, I'd assign four stars for an enjoyable, action packed ride that blends splendid actors with a compelling story and effectively married cinematography and CGI special effects.
From a technical perspective, this is an old DVD with a letterboxed non-anamorphic transfer. In 2004 this is unacceptable. It's particularly unforgiveable given this film's high-tech orientation and the fact that anamorphic transfers are no more expensive to produce than letterbox.
I recommend NOT purchasing this title unless and until Touchstone updates the transfer. By that time, a side benefit might be a Special Edition with the extras this film deserves. A DTS sound track would be a worthy bonus.
Enemy of the State (1998) - Review written on May 31, 2004
Rating: 3 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 5 did not.
Director: Tony Scott
Cast: Will Smith, Gene Hackman, Jon Voight, Regina King, Loren Dean, Jake Busey, Barry Pepper.
Running Time: 127 minutes.
Rated R for violence and language.
Another producer Jerry Bruckheimer/director Tony Scott thrill ride without substance, this time pitting family man lawyer Robert Clayton Dean (played by Will Smith in a ho-hum performance) against a technologically-driven government. Not knowing that the trivial meeting with an old friend would cause him so much trouble, Dean gets sucked into a conspiracy case involving a rogue National Security Agent (Jon Voight) who killed a United States congressman because he accidentally received a video tape with footage of the murder. With incredible surveillance techniques and technology, Voight is able to track all of the lawyer's moves and keep tabs on him.
Our hero's life is turned upside down until he meets up with a stealthy former NSA active named Brill (played very well by Gene Hackman). With the assistance of Brill, Dean attacks the government head on and must learn the truth in order to save his life. Director Tony Scott brilliantly uses the camera to portray his views, jolting the characters through a series of incredible chase scenes, rip-roaring explosions, and intense firearm combat, but ultimately "Enemy of the State" focuses solely on the unbridled advances in special effects abilities that it keeps the audience from understanding the story and getting involved with the characters. Smith is only adequate in his first major "dramatic" role, while Hackman and Voight pick up some of the slack in their devilishly effective parts. A must-see if you are into big explosions and dynamite cinematography, but one to leave on the shelf if over-acting and a mediocre script are an annoyance.
For what it is, perfect - Review written on April 20, 2004
Rating: 4 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful.
Enemy of the State is a breakneck thriller that genuinely keeps you on the edge of your seat and is a real nail-biter. It is incredibly well-constructed for what it is: slick, well-shot, gloriously pacey and even with a dash of interesting social question in there. Granted, often it is incredibly implausible, and his ability to sit back and be happy at the end despite all the carnage of what has happened, make it a little laughable, but the fact is, thats not the point with this kind of film - the point is it is truly thrilling, stylish and cool. You really get deep into it.
Will Smith is startlingly good in his best performance since Six Degrees Of Seperation - if only he would turn in these great performances in credible, interesting films more often, and is well supported by a strong cast that includes Gene Hackman, Jamie Kennedy and Jack Black amongst others. This comes highly reccomended for an evening's entertainment and is truly exhilirating and packed with plot and intrigue that puts most regurgitated, lame excuses for a storyline to shame. Great stuff.
Slickly produced but laughably implausible --- 2 1/2 stars - Review written on January 12, 2004
Rating: 2 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 9 did not.
This is supposed to be a thriller. OK, whatever...the viewer obviously knows that Will Smith will emerge from this harrowing adventure more or less intact, so there really isn't any tension created by putting his character in peril. Therefore, the only tension & suspense the producers of this film can hope to create comes from playing on the audience's sense of paranoia. "Oh my god, what if the government really IS watching my every word & deed?" thinks the audience. Oh my god, this could actually be happening! All you have to do is read some of the reviews here and you will see that paranoia is a major factor in this film's appeal.
All I could think of as I watched this film is, give me a break. One rogue NSA bureaucrat, supported by a handfull of computer geeks, and they are supposed to be able to conduct an operation this vast? Are you kidding me? Has anyone ever heard of information overload? I don't doubt that a good deal of this technology exists, but let's get real folks --- if the NSA was really conducting surveillance on this scale, the amount of raw data the agency would have to sift through simply boggles the mind. The NSA would have to employ half the population of the USA to spy on the other half. If the NSA's surveillance is this bush-league, most of us could commit all manner of security breaches and never get caught! Ironically, I found myself feeling more secure about not being scrutinized by the government after having seen this film.
As to the film itself --- sure, all the chase scenes were gripping, the camera angles were great, blah blah blah. The production values in this movie are top-notch, but so what? Bruckheimer & Tony Scott can do movies like this in their sleep, so it's no big deal. The same can be said for Jon Voight & Gene Hackman, who pretty much phone it in with their roles. From a production standpoint, this movie is indistinguishable from the hundreds of other so-called thrillers that the Hollywood machine has churned out over the last few years. Ho hum. Overall, this just really was a thoroughly mediocre film.
the suspense never let's go - Review written on December 05, 2003
Rating: 4 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 1 did not.
Jason Lee(A Guy Thing) takes shots of Jon Voight(Midnight Cowboy) killing Jason Robards(Magnolia) and Lee before he gets runned over by a bus makes Will Smith(Bad Boys 1 and 2) and then Voight and his crew ggo after him and his family. Smith gets help from Gene Hackman(Scarcrow). other actors in the mix...Jack Black(Shallow Hal), Jamie Kennedy(Scream Trilogy), Lisa Bonet(High Fidelity), Scott Caan(Black and White), Ian Hart(Harry Potter and The Chamber Of Secrets), Tom Sizemore(Dreamcatcher), Loren Dean(Rosewood), Jake Busey(Identity), Barry Pepper(Battlefield Earth), Gabriel Bryne(Stigmata), Stuart Wilson(No Escape) and an unbilled cameo by Seth Green(Party Monster). dont miss the ride.
It could'a been more... - Review written on September 14, 2003
Rating: 3 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
I love the cast in this film. Hackman and Smith have done some really excellent work. While I generally enjoyed this film for what it was, it could have been much more. I am somehow reminded of "Conspiracy Theory" in that it was a disappointment considering the possibilities it offered. Mostly, the problem is in the basic premise of the story. Any one of thousands of conflicts could have been played out, but instead, we see a personal crime in Voigt's character taken out on an unsuspecting citizen. This may sound minor, but we could have seen a glimpse of some big-brother massacre, and the minor hero who overcomes it. Some of what is offered here makes you wonder (in worried fascination) what is possible, but generally I can say this is NOT a must-see movie. If you saw Conspiracy Theory, don't bother with this one. I give it 3 stars in case you didn't catch Conspiracy Theory, otherwise, 2 stars.