Amazon.com Customer Reviews
The will to systematize - Review written on May 23, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
Grids have been at the forefront of visual design for several decades now, and in the latest turn of events, they are being rigorously applied to the subject of web-design. The latter case was what motivated me to take a look at this book.
Showcase examples, and their visual and verbal deconstruction dominate much of the book. In terms of actual content, history and tips, Timothy Samara does a good job on the intro, but I was left wanting for more, hence the four star rating. Overall, it is a worthwhile investment, but it needs to be complimented by further reading.
A great book on handling type and layout - Review written on January 11, 2005
Rating: 4 out of 5
20 customers found this review helpful.
This is a developed look at handling type and page (surface) layout in a simple-yet-abstract way. Using grids and ideas presented in this book (with some practise), the learning designer can begin to utilise elements once thought as simple and static in ways which add dynamism to your layouts.
For a designer such as myself, a fan of Swiss and Bauhaus, simplicity, directness, Making and Breaking the Grid is a book full of idea and potential. Although not radical per se, it is a concise look at one of the most powerful aspects of communication design out there, in my opinion. Definitely worth a look.
A first caveat - Review written on March 30, 2003
Rating: 3 out of 5
25 customers found this review helpful, 79 did not.
This is not a full review of the book. It is an initial caveat to purchasers. If you are the sort of graphic designer who is mightily impressed by references to the 'poststructural French philospher Rene Foucault' (reproduced with original spelling from page 117 of the book) then you will find this highly stimulating, and admire the pretty pictures.
If, on the other hand, you find such ignorance laughable, or feel that a half-decent writer (never mind editor) should catch such howlers, then you may have pause for thought. It is a philosophical issue, of course: some believe that graphic design should have such contempt for mere words that they can be ignored, set in Dingbats or otherwise mutilated. Such an opinion is, however, not entirely in accord with many designers referenced in this book. A deliberate contradiction on the part of the author? I don't think so.
So, shoddily edited, but looks nice.