Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Why isn't this dvd in a full screen format? - Review written on May 13, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
I love this movie!! Being a younger sister I can identify with Gillian...
Also being the one in my family who is different( yes ,i'm a musical witch)
I know how it feels when People look down their nose at you,call you names etc
I love the "there's a little witch in all of us"line
How ever ,my only question is why isn;'t the dvd in a full screen format as well?
Hardly any movies ( whether they're on dvd , or at the theatres) are in the wide screen format...
I find it very difficult to watch the film when it's in widescreen...
because it hurts my eyes... Besides this isn't true wide screen since widescreen actually should show almost half of the picture( movie),and not 1/3 of it!!!
how it feels when People look down their nose at you,call you names etc
I love the "there's a little witch in all of us"line
How ever ,my only question is why isn;'t the dvd in a full screen format as well?
Hardly any movies ( whether they're on dvd , or at the theatres) are in the wide screen format...
I find it very difficult to watch the film when it's in widescreen...
because it hurts my eyes... Besides this isn't true wide screen since widescreen actually should show almost half of the picture( movie),and not 1/3 of it!!!
I Beg To Differ - Stick With The Book - Review written on January 17, 2008
Rating: 1 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 3 did not.
This disappointing film has none of the irony and wistful quality that made Alice Hoffman's book of the same name such a - well, magical read. The film instead is ruined by a rushed, connect-the-dots script that fails utterly to capture the nuances and charm that made the book such a hit when it was published.
One reviewer characterized the film, which received mostly poor reviews, thusly: "Barbie joins a coven." To be fair to Bullock and Kidman, the "Barbies" in question, there wasn't much they could do with the awful script. That aside, the review could not be more apt. A good cast, including Aidan Quinn, an actor I greatly respect, can't redeem the bad writing that reduces the original material to cute gimmicks and a dreadful ending that not only doesn't appear in the book, but runs contrary to the book's underlying observations about the relationship between desire and wisdom.
I cannot recommend the book highly enough. I cannot recommend the movie at all.
One of my favorite films - Review written on October 01, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
This has long been one of my favorite "feel good" movies, and when my VHS tape finally burned out, I decided to invest in a DVD. I am glad I did, as the extras are great, along with the movie. I was thrilled to find it for a reasonable cost, and the service was three times faster than I expected it to be. It was supposed to be here by the 24th of the month and it got here two weeks earlier than that. I have never been disappointed in the acting in this movie, the story is very good, and it ends well. While it is quite different from the book by Alice Hoffman, that doesn't seem to detract from it for me. However, I will say that I didn't read the book until after I had seen the movie. It might be different if I had done it the other way around.