Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Academic/math background of author clearly evident - great presentation - Review written on August 12, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
20 customers found this review helpful.
As a C-family programmer with a math background, I found the author's approach to presentation to be excellent: in 3 critical ways.
1) Unlike most VB books, he separates IDE (Integrated Devel. Env.) issues from the actual coding examples. In other words, while the IDE treatment is good, one needn't concern oneself with the IDE in order to understand the fundamental attributes - both syntactic and semantic - of the language. To put it as simply as possible: my objective was to know *what the code looks like, and what it does* as a language, not as a language-cum-development environment. (It's also worth noting that Visual Studio is *not* the only available development environment.)
2) The author spends a lot of time on definitions, and doesn't assume any pre-existing knowledge of the language. Syntax charts appear before presentation of any language construct, so that the reader can clearly see what options are available for that language construct *before* the author begins to actually describe the variations.
3) The examples rely on forms *only* when necessary. From what I can tell, most VB books are addressed to VB programmers - who seem to think of the entire language as being built around forms. (While this may be a historically understandable view, clearly it's inaccurate, given that it's possible to write form-independent and useful component code, such as for use in an ASP .NET application.)
Let me close by saying that after struggling through a number of VB books that were clearly oriented towards forms and/or holding the reader by the hand when it came to walking through the IDE in *every single example*, but were relatively weak when it came to the fundamental syntactic and semantic characteristics of the language, it was a pleasure to read this text, in which *definitions* and *semantics* came first!
If you are looking to have your hand held so you can walk through each example with the IDE, or seeking a "cookbook" that will tell you how to write such-and-such a routine, this may not be the right book for you. But as a programmer who has learned many languages, the first thing I want to know with any new language is: *how to write the code in plain text, and what the code I've written will actually do*.
After reading another Wrox tome (the title of which I won't mention), browsing at my local B&N, and consulting many possible resources on line, this is the best text that I've found which satisfies that seemingly simple-minded criterion. And at Amazon's excellent price, this is a bargain you can't afford to pass up!
Useful VB 2005 Book - Review written on June 16, 2006
Rating: 4 out of 5
17 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
This is a doorstop size book that contains a lot of very useful information, explanation and guidance.
The author has an easy to read style, which doesn't avoid technical terms, but doesn't wallow in them just to impress you either. The book contains four main parts covering a wide range of VB2005 topics, plus a very useful set of Appendices.
Part 1:Visual Studio IDE.
I think there is always a dilemma for authors when describing the IDE. On the one hand, if they are not careful they end up producing a long boring list of toolbars, windows, menus, etc, which will soon have the reader nodding off over the book. On the other, if they describe each of these elements in detail, you would probably end up with a 1000 page book that never gets past the IDE description.
The author has walked the line between these two extremes, dropping in additional detail on key areas as necessary. For instance in the section on Project Properties and the Compile Tab, he makes use of the opportunity to reinforce the positive reasons for having Option Explicit and Option Strict turned on.
Similarly, he includes real world examples of how you might find particular Debug menu windows useful.
Part 2: Object Oriented Programming
The section on OOP contains a good introduction to key principles and practices in this area. Clear code samples to demonstrate points and useful diagrams to clarify the tricky areas all help demystify what can be a difficult subject for newcomers.
I particularly liked the detailed section on Collection Classes, but would have liked more on the relatively
new area of Generics .
As OOP is a topic that many Classic VB upgraders will have to get to grips with, this Part of the book will give them a useful introduction to the subject.
Part 3: Graphics.
This Part of the book is really excellent. If you have visited the VB-Helper web site you will know that Rod Stephens is an absolute master in this field and his skills shine through in this section.
He manages to explain a whole range of graphics topics very clearly - and not just the relatively easy stuff. Difficult techniques such as Transformations and Graphics Paths are well explained with description, code samples and screenshots.
I found that the downloadable sample code was particularly useful in this part as I was able to copy/paste and recycle some of the advanced examples for a project I was working on at the time.
Part 4: Interacting with the Environment.
This final Part includes coverage of a range of topics, including Configuration, Resources (much improved in VB2005), Streams, Useful Namespaces, and a wide review of File and IO issues.
Summary
It is clearly written. The Graphics section is extremely good. In fact it is the best coverage of the topic of GDI+ for VB.NET that I have yet seen.
Overall this is a good Programmer to Programmer level book which has plenty of code samples, clear narrative and comprehensive coverage of important topics. Apart from anything else, personally I think this book is worth the asking price just for the information contained in the Graphics Part alone.
Positioned just above the absolute beginner - Review written on October 19, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
47 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
This book is positioned somewhere between Beginner and Intermediate. It begins with Visual Studio's integrated development environment (ICE). If you've programed in something before, most of the concepts of the IDE and of the language itself will make sense to you and allow you to become productive quickly. I don't think it would matter which language you have used, just being a bit familiar with the programming concept is enough.
The book begins with a fairly quick overview or introduction to the IDE, the language and an introduction to programming. This lasts about a third of the book, maybe a bit more. At the end of this time you will have a good overview of the language. Part II of the book covers object oriented concepts, classes, structures, namespaces, collection classes, generics. Part III is called graphics, but it also includes things like printing and producing reports using Crystal Reports. Part IV is called Interacting with the Environment and is on using external resources such as the system registry, files, streaming data and so on. By the end of Part IV, you will be a fairly accomplished programmer.
The last third of the book is a series of appendicies. These provide a concise reference book for the language. This is a convenient way to combine the tutorial approach with the reference book approach that will give the book greater usefulness as you actually work in the language.