Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Solid introduction to basic, bad panorama coverage - Review written on November 20, 2004
Rating: 4 out of 5
6 customers found this review helpful.
This is a very solid and well written introduction to the basics, from managing photos to doing simple color correction and touchups. The book is in full color and the examples are of regular people and average pictures that present the problems we have all come to know, and wish to fix, underexposure, overexposure, too much shadow, too little contrast, etc.
Overall I like the book but there are some rough spots. In particular, the coverage of panoramas could be better. The author admonishes you not to pay for panorama software, which he overshoots on the price, and then lays out a complex set of steps that will result in an average panorama that will likely have perspective problems if you take the shots too close. In addition there was more that could have been said about the RAW format, which is critical to getting the most out of your camera.
Still, even with the downsides, this is a good book for digital photographers.
Top Notch Book, Well Written and Laid Out! - Review written on September 21, 2004
Rating: 5 out of 5
19 customers found this review helpful.
This is a very good book. In fact it is by far the best I have found to guide me in taking images from camera to use! Comprehensive, but easy to follow and read.
I am not a professional photographer, but I do take a lot of photographs. Some for fun, but many find their way into our company's website, PowerPoint slides, and promotional material (engineering and industrial projects). I also use a lot of photographs for my wife's travel business website and brochures. Mostly slides for years, but am now going "all digital." They all need adjusting, cropping, sharpening, fixing so I find myself using Photoshop more and more.
I started using Photoshop 5.0 almost 6 years ago, about the time I purchased a scanner and started trying to master inserting images in documents for my work. I was no computer amateur, but what a struggle. I fumbled through at least two of the obscure "list everything and every option" manuals Kelby describes-with time consuming, mediocre results. Finally admitted defeat and enrolled in a Photoshop night course at university. Three years, Photoshop 7.1, Win2000, and many thousands of photographs later, I am still learning. I read through parts of this book at a local bookstore three weeks ago and quickly concluded that this was a book I had to have. Just got it today, and have actually read a third already!
Good, solid advice on using Photoshop's browser was the first thing that caught my attention. I was using the limited "Zoom Browser" software that came with my new Canon digital camera and wasn't even aware of the browser capabilities of Photoshop. Also appreciated the advice on sharpening settings, some of which I had already noted from the class I took on Photoshop. I had been investigating sharpening plug-ins for Photoshop, and Kelby's examples are a good introduction to the different sharpening effects. Next will be colour curves and adjustments-which, despite appearances of my photos, I am still making a mess of!
The book is very well laid out. Use of colour and white space is nicely done. Easy to read and follow, and generously illustrated with colour photographs for every step. In fact, this is one of my criteria for an instructional book-if it's not "easy on the eye" it will probably just sit on the shelf. Of course, eye candy can grow old quickly without content. Kelby covers the subject well in an informal and humorous style. His advice is right on, and to the point: I have photos, now I need to use them-even if it's only to e-mail friends and family. He lays out how to do this.
The Best PS Book for Digital Photographers - Review written on May 02, 2004
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
The moment I leafed through this book I was impressed. I picked up several useful tips in the first few minutes perusing it. This never happens - usually I look through a PS book looking for things that I don't know already.
Scott Kelby doesn't waste time telling you how to take a photograph, but rather gets to the meat and potatoes of digital post processing. This is great for me, as I need to make the most of my time and this book has helped me to do that.
Also, I really enjoy Mr. Kelby's writing style, and am oh-so glad that he came out with this book - it's the best thing to come along for digital photographers like myself, who have a working knowledge of PS but need to squeeze as much as possible out of the program.
My sincere thanks Mr. Kelby! :-) I love this book!
This book has it all! - Review written on December 18, 2003
Rating: 5 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful.
I received this book for my birthday this last October and its been a god send. It has all kinds of tips that one wouldn't think of using.
The main thing I like about this book is that it shows you ways to fix those photos that didn't turn out so good. For instance it shows you how to remove a shadow from someone's face that you've snapped. Someone has acne problems? That's simple.
Although it seems really simple now the best thing I learned was how to get quality prints from the digital photos I took (basically change the DPI!).
Learning these techniques are very easy as each one is done in a step by step fashion. Scott even gives some advanced tips that beginners can do as well (IMHO)
I'd recommend this book to anyone who has an interest in digital photography and wants to make their photos look as good as possible.
A must for former darkroom photographers. - Review written on November 13, 2003
Rating: 5 out of 5
8 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
Darkroom photographers learn to analyze a photo. This book takes the analyses you have perfected over the years and tells you how to use Photoshop 7 to perfect your images. The step by step approach focuses on the process, not the myriad of possibilities with every Photoshop tool. From the first image you work with using this book, you will quickly get results, and begin to build your knowledge of Photoshop.
The book sits beside my monitor, and is used several times a week. Wish my kids came with instructions like this...
Fantastic book if you understand the purpose of it... - Review written on October 22, 2003
Rating: 5 out of 5
8 customers found this review helpful.
This book is NOT about ...
- how do I scan my pictures in
- how do I use photoshop and all the features in it.
This book is about...
- I have some problems with my digital photos
- I need to color correct
- I need to sharpen the image
- I need to reduce red eye
- I need to fix skin tones
- etc
The introduction of the book best summarizes his approach..."He does x number of seminars every year for hundreds of professional photographers, they all ask the same questions on how to fix digital photos for the customer." This book summarizes all the tips and tricks to get the job done.
I couldn't be happier with the book, it has exactly what I want in it.
You might get a helpful tip - Review written on October 15, 2003
Rating: 3 out of 5
15 customers found this review helpful.
Scott Kelby's book is a recipe book for certain discrete problems that the Photoshop user may encounter, as well as some little known information about some aspects of Photoshop that you might not otherwise learn. If you find a recipe that fills a need that you have, the book will be a good investment. But if you are looking for an overall approach to using Photoshop this is not the book for you.
Right from the first chapter, with his discussion of ways to use the Photoshop browser, you make pick up another way of dealing with a Photoshop function that you didn't know about. On the other hand, some of the material will be old hat to an experienced Photoshop user.
Some of the techniques, like color correction of digital images, will appeal to almost any Photoshop user. Those who have philosophical questions about what I call montage may not be interested in chapters on removing the wrinkles in an elderly person's portrait or removing the love handles from a slightly overgrown physique. On the other hand, these certainly are bread and butter issues to some photographers.
Kelby's method of holding your attention is by making a number of breezy wise cracks as you go through the book. For example he says in the chapter on masking techniques "If I were elected President, one of my first priorities would be to sign an executive order requiring all registered voters to carry with them a white seamless role at all times" He then goes on to speculate how easy this would make Photoshop selection. That stylistic gadget may make you laugh the first time you encounter it, but after the 50th encounter you want to tell the author to take a break.
The title of this book might lead you to believe that this book would start at the beginning of the photographic process, when an image is being captured in a digital camera. If the book didn't intend to cover this, why say it's for "digital photographers"? After all, every picture manipulated in Photoshop is digital - it has to be to get into Photoshop - but it could have come from a photo-cd or a scanner. But this book starts when the photo is already in the camera.
I got very interested when I saw that there was a section of the book on Photoshop's Camera RAW plug-in. But all Kelby gives you is a rehash of the information that Adobe provides you with the RAW software with a lower level of detail. You get no help on how to use that software to make a better picture.
I occasionally think Kelby takes a more complex approach to a problem than one needs. His section on "Color Correcting Digital Images" advises setting the tonal highlight, shadow and midpoint with the curves function, but most users would probably find it easier to do this with the levels function
There is no magic bullet that will help someone learn the fundamentals of Photoshop. The new user is best served by sitting down with a book of tutorials, either like those provided by Adobe or like Photoshop 7 Artistry by Barry Haynes, and working through the exercises. After that you can come back to this book and get a few tips in using the Photoshop functions that you know.
Looks very nice, but not much substance here. - Review written on October 13, 2003
Rating: 1 out of 5
12 customers found this review helpful, 8 did not.
This is one of two books on Photoshop I've bought by mail-order this year, and I wish I'd looked it over before I paid for it. It looks great, with lots of color pictures on every page, but there's not much of substance here. It's pretty much the same old techniques you can find in dozens of other books, laid out in an interesting and colorful way.
Beginners to Photoshop may find something useful here, but if you're a serious digital photographer or veteran Photoshop user, you'll probably want to look elsewhere.