Amazon.com Customer Reviews
A very useful book - Review written on August 24, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
I've bought more than my share of Flash books over the years and I can tell you that here's one that I return to a lot. The title is very appropriate: I've used this book for a number of jobs at work and each one has worked fine and made me look good. The projects are all very practical. The video chapter, in which you create captions for video, was particularly helpful. The "gathering tool", which helps you attach captions to your video, is, as they say, worth the price of admission alone, as is the powerpoint-style flash presentation technique. I don't know any other way to accomplish what Kerman has done here: without an advanced level of Flash (an intermediate understanding of Flash is good) a person is able to do some pretty advanced projects. Kerman has taken away the need to do many of the advanced and no doubt confusing parts of the project and allows the reader to do the rest on their own. And, in the end you understand enough of what you did so you can customize the projects. Heck, I'd like to see him do another one of these books. I've got a lot of other projects at work that need his expertise. 5 stars.
Utterly useless, unless you're already an expert - Review written on May 24, 2006
Rating: 1 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 10 did not.
Ya know the strange thing about the lessons in this book? They don't teach you anything, beyond how to take the lessons in this book.
The author apparently suffers from the delusion that everyone understands actionscripting as much as he does. His "introduction to actionscript" dsoesn't really explain much, and is remarkable in its superficiality. The author then then plunges into a series of lessons that are long on script, but pretty much devoid of any explanation of what you're actually doing.
If you like following pages of directions, and not actually LEARNING anything, this book is DEFINITELY for you. If you're looking for an educational resource that that will allow you to grasp actionscripting, and know how to customize it to your needs, look elsewhere, because this book just doesn't deliver.
Practical API to get the job done - Review written on March 28, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
25 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
I debated whether to give it 4 stars or 5 stars, at the end I gave it 5. Here is the run down of the book:
What this book does NOT do:
- Teach you how to create an API.
- Teach you Flash 8 from beginner to expert (this is NOT a tutorial or anything similar)
- Teach you ActionScript
What this book does do:
- Give you working APIs for real projects.
- Explain to you how to work with the particular APIs.
- Get you thinking about ActionScript as a full featured programming language.
- Get your work done, hiding in the API a lot of the complexity.
- Saves you time.
If you are looking for a tutorial on flash, you will find many, though I haven't been particularly impressed by any Flash tuotrial book up to date. And this book was never set to be a tutorial, it goes straight to the project.
I would highly recommend this book for those busy professionals that have a lot of projects come up and who don't have the time to learn yet another programming language. I consider myself at an intermediate level in flash, but a beginner in Actionscript.
Phillip Kerman did a very good job in providing several "projects and techniques to get the job done". Which was what he set up to do with this book, and hence he gets 5 full stars. This book saved me about 20-30 hours of research and coding I would have required to create a couple of projects.
If you are looking for a tutorial on Flash 8 or Actionscript stay away from this book. However, if you are looking for high quality, working Flash 8 code that you can customize for your own projects, it would be hard to find a better one.
A much needed Flash 8 book! - Review written on March 17, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
31 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
I was very pleasantly surprised to find this book. I've enjoyed Mr. Kerman's books in the past, they're always very informative and practical. And I think that's the key: practical. I like using Flash and I love making Flash projects, but I find ActionScript a really cumbersome language. It's no Ruby. That's fine, but I don't want a book that's cumbersome too.
Creating Flash projects over and over again, you definitely realize there are certain patterns to your work. You need video, you need a preloader, you need to parse XML files, etc. A lot of books try to cover everything available to a Flash programmer and end up really telling you very little. By focusing in on what's important, Mr. Kerman has written something very close to a masterpiece in the field.
Chapter 1 is an excellent overview of the new features in Flash 8, and frankly I wasn't even aware of half of them because Macromedia doesn't really emphasize the new features of the ActionScript language, they emphasize the authoring environment and the visuals. Chapter 2 is an overview of constructing a real-world Flash project and it is priceless. You become a great Flash developer when you see how a Flash project is really just a lot of pieces put together. You learn in this chapter how to break apart your projects, how to arrange content, and so forth. It's an excellent prelude to the rest of the book.
The rest of the chapters of the book (and contents of the CD-ROM) cover eight projects similar to the types of real-world projects I've been doing lately. I'm not going to cover them all, they're all really good, but let's take some examples from the Portfolio chapter. This is an excellent example of what's great about this book. This chapter takes you through building modular components that you put together to make a portfolio. The thumbnails are separate from the larger views, and they are separate from the chapter navigation. You don't build one project, really, but as many as you want! You can combine these things as much as you want. And when you're ready, dig into the libraries that you didn't have to study in detail. You have worked up from a great foundation, but you're well entitled to play with the foundation too, if you want!
If you find yourself building Flash projects, especially websites, that are of any real size, you should really get a copy of this book. The writing is great, the code is solid and the possibilities are endless. And for this price it's a downright bargain.
Finally, a really great book on Flash 8!