Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Over-rated, over-rated, over-rated - Review written on August 16, 2007
Rating: 2 out of 5
19 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
I bought this book after reading all the rave reviews. At the time I was a beginner PHP programmer with very little programming experience. When I got my hands on this book I was very excited, until I got past the crash course.
For a beginner, this book has too many pages without examples. It just goes too deep. For me, I need a page of description and then an exercise to see how things work. There are sections of this book which go on forever without examples, and the writers say you can do things this way, or that way etc etc. This is just confusing and too dry to hold my attention.
I have quite a few PHP books, 90% of which I have regretted buying. Online tutorials are much better of you want to learn from scratch, you'll pick up more techniques and develop a lot faster by doing these tutorials, most of which are free. One book that does stand out as being an excellent PHP book is 'PHP Solutions' by David Powers. From start to finish this is just a great book. Clear, concise and just a few paragraphs of text before you start exercises. In the space of a couple of weeks I really felt like I had improved, and it reinforced much of what I had learnt from doing online tutorials. 'PHP Solutions' is the best out there for PHP Development... Welling & Thompsons book falls way short in my opinion.
Excellent Book for PHP and MySQL - Review written on March 04, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful.
This book is worth every penny. I bought it after buying many other PHP and MySQL books. You are exposed to the code right away. The book will have you programming fairly quickly, doing real world stuff, and progressing fast. They express the language exactly the right way, and is well laid out. This book is made a diamond in the rough because they make the language seem so easy, and never let it get boring; they keep it interesting.
A huge plus is also that they tell you in the appendix, which they reference in Chapter 1, how to setup a web server (Apache) on Unix and Windows, get MySQL and PHP installed and running with the server and Apache, and cover every detail so that a newbe can understand it line by line. They explain all the options to fill out while setup of everything, which versions to use, and if something needs something in a config. file, they tell you where to find it and exactly what and where to insert code.
They also make everything visually scannable so that you can use it as a reference as well, or if you understand the details but are just looking for the syntax for something, etc.
Overall, this book is not only the best you can get, but probably as best as a guide can be written. My words cannot complement it enough. I am an electronics guy, very much like some previous post, but this book helps me understand the software very well. This book maximizes the reader's success. Enough said.
not that great - Review written on November 11, 2005
Rating: 3 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful, 11 did not.
I was catched by the hype "best book" and so on, so now I'm reading it, though i'm only on page 200, but still the book isn't so great. Sometimes I think I'd better read PHP online manual, but not the book (now I'm reading both), because authors sometimes misleadingly present information. For example with __set() and __get() methods in the class, authors claim that these methods are always implicitly invoked when setting the value, but PHP manual clearly states "These methods will only be triggered when your object or inherited object doesn't contain the member or method you're trying to access".
Chapter about objects is very weak, I wonder if I hadn't previous experience with Java, I guess I wouldn't understand at all what objects and classes are, what they do, how they do it and so on.
Overall I can't judge if the book is better or worse than other PHP books, this is my first on the subject, so I give it a 3 stars.
I wish Bruce Eckel would write a book on PHP :)
I can't recommend this book highly enough! - Review written on September 24, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
15 customers found this review helpful.
This book will help you understand everything you want to understand about PHP and MySQL, period.
This is the second book I've read by Luke Welling and Laura Thompson, and I have to say that they produce incredibly well-organized and well-conceived books that teach whatever subjects they tackle remarkably well.
I have read many other PHP books on the market, and this book is covers the topic, both in breadth and depth, far greater than any other book I've read.
You may have heard that MySQL and PHP come with significant security considerations. Try to find a plain-english explanation of these security considerations in any other popular PHP book out there, and you'll be disappointed. After reading this book, you will be able to make informed security decisions that don't simply parrot the prescriptive security measures described in other texts.
Beyond simply recommending this book, I recommend the authors. If you're considering *any* topic that this writing duo has addressed, I recommend them, hands down. Their writing style is clear, the examples are methodical and concise, and their explanations are extremely informative!