Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Backward fan - Review written on October 17, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review not to be helpful.
I started backward. I watched all the Harry Potter movies--and got lost. I really didn't see what all the hype was about. Somebody told me it was "simple": wave wand about, have unicorns and giants...the usual fantasy. I had no desire to "find out what happens". Yeah, I'd probably go watch the remaining movies, only because I like magic and wizards and special effects but go out and buy the last two books? Nah.
Then one day I picked up a used Harry Potter book at a garage sale and thought I'd find out what all the fuss was about; after all, books are supposed to be better than the movie.
It was cool enough to buy the last two books, but honestly, the plot of the Deathly Hallows was confusing and I really didn't want to put in that much effort into a book.
Someone recommended that I start at the very beginning with the Sorcerer's Stone...
The entire collection (books, audio cd, and dvd) later, Harry Potter got me angry, frustrated...I wanted Hermione to "give it a rest, already!"...and Ron! Don't even get me started on him!
In a way I am glad that I didn't have to wait for each book to be written, because there were times I truly disliked almost everyone of the characters. But by the end, (as I re-read)by the last chapter of THIS book, I had thoroughly loved the three friends as I would my own kids of impossible teenagers.
The Deadly Hallows has a complicated plot that readers that has not read the previous books (and I mean "read", the movie doesn't explain enough)will find difficult to follow. But it is a book that feeds the hunger the characters of Harry Potter has managed to create. Anything less would have been a let down.
Two parts were especially wonderful...the entire house elf saga with Dobby and Kreacher was priceless. Their drama queen manner was funny but touching. I laughed, smiled, and cried.
The other was the incredible, enduring love between Harry's arch enemy teacher and Harry's beloved mother. For 6 books, we were led to believe in the greatness of Dumbledore, only to learn that he was quite human with all it's failings. We also believed in the nastiness of Snape. To find out that he was really noble...and that as a boy he had been hurt and yet managed to love as none of the others, the so called good guys, had love was emotionally amazing.
I wanted to give this book 4 stars for all the grief this series had given me...then I realized that only a 5 star book can get a reader that worked up.
Yeah, I could find a dozen things wrong with this book (as other reviewers had) and those books that came before it, but in the end, if Harry, Hermione, Ron, Dobby and all the rest was real enough to make you believe for a span of time, then it has done it's job.
The Fitting Conclusion of the Fantastic Tale of the Boy Who Lived - Review written on October 13, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
After 6 epic novels, the tale of Harry Potter finally comes to a close in The Deathly Hallows. As a fervent Potter fan, this can be nothing but bittersweet. There are few living authors that can keep you engaged in the way J.K. Rowling can. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows is a tremendous novel, a fitting conclusion to the end of one of the greatest stories of post-modern fiction.
J.K. Rowling is a unique author in that that, above all things, she is a storyteller. She doesn't delve into the deepest reaches of the human condition, questioning the metaphysical, or shed light on uncomfortable truths. She tells stories. Harry Potter, like the fairy tales that influenced her is a story of good and evil, the power of love and compassion persevering despite unthinkable obstacles and tragic loss. The formula has been done a million of times before, but she presents it in such a way that seems fresh and new. She goes through a conscious effort to tie emotional responses to the character's actions. There are times this comes across as overly melodramatic, but there is no denying it's effect. You care about Harry Potter and his comrades unlike few characters in post-modern fiction. The formula for a good story starts with an emotional attachment to the character's actions and reactions, and at this there is no denying her success.
The novel, like all her previous works, is written plainly. Sentences are short and succinct, dialog quick and snappy. This deliberately simplistic style causes the novel to flow effortlessly from one harrowing event to the next. The beauty is not in the language itself, but rather, in the fantastic plot it creates. There are some that credit this "simple" writing as catering to children, but this conclusion does Mrs. Rowling a grave disservice. True, this clearly isn't Joyce, but plain, simple, writing has its own charm and allure, she never lets the words get in the way of the story, and as a storyteller, this is paramount.
Compared to the previous Harry Potter novels, this is the most well-conceived since The Goblet of Fire. The action never lulls, like it does at times in The Half-Blood Prince, and throughout The Order of the Phoenix. The ending was conceived before she began book one, and this is apparent from the very beginning. Action starts from chapter one and remains consistent till the very end. The grim ending of The Half-Blood Prince is the perfect segway into The Deathly Hallows, as tragedy and struggle follow the characters every step of the way. To me, it seems that Mrs. Rowling struggled to get through books five and six because she had all of this amazing content bottled up for the epic final novel. She had to flesh out the events leading up to the end, but refrain from revealing her biggest plot twists and turns for the last full measure.
The novel does have it's faults, however. I believe she got overzealous in executing her characters. She wanted to portray that this is a war, and in war there are casualties, but she goes overboard. At times characters die for no apparent reason other than to raise the body count. She clearly does this emphisize the burden on Potter's shoulders, but she got a little carried away.
The novel, thankfully, explains all the previous mysteries that has plagued Harry for all of these years, and does so very elegantly. I hope this is the last we hear about Harry Potter and his comrades. Not because I don't want to hear about their future trials and tribulations, but like any good story, it must end. The story finally reaches its denouement, and anything else would serve to only tarnish it's greatness. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hollows is a testament to the power of good storytelling. While other author's try to mimic Hemingway and Faulkner, J.K. Rowling has a singular pursuit, to tell a great story, the fantastic tale of the Boy Who Lived, and at this, she has few equals.
Dazzling! Highly anticipated saga reveals a breathtaking conclusion. - Review written on September 09, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
Harry Potter...this name has been echoed all across the globe, and J.K. Rowling's phenomenon has been wrapped up with exciting and satisfying finale. Fans hungrily awaited the highly anticipated midnight release date, eying the fresh copies with a look of pure greed in there eye. Among these people, I finally received my copy, and it was cradled warmly in my arms. Getting home in a frenzy, the novel was finished before morning, and I, and the majority of the fan community, had not been disappointed.
Prior to this exciting night, we have all wondered and fantasized; Whose side is Snape really on? Who would triumph; Voldemort or Harry? What exactly is the "Deathly Hallows"? Will Ron and Hermione finally get together? What had Dumbledore seen in the Mirror of Erised? Who would die? Who could be trusted? The suspense cackled to the awaiting community, till I thought I was going mad with anticipation.
The novel begins a little slowly yet satisfyingly, but soon morphs into a thrilling broomstick chase. It pleases me that action happens early in this book, making me urgent to read on. Things seem peaceful in the burrow, and the wedding was going smoothly when it's interrupted by the vicious Death Eaters, and things suddenly transform from a light, carefree occasion to the suspenseful aura of life and death. From there, this volume progresses, tension rising till it tilts at a breath-taking climax. However, the final outcome was slightly predictable with the death of Lord Voldemort.
The intricate plot goes all the way back to book one, weaving the sentences and storylines to form a complex rug of color. The twists and turns made this a page-turner, and my eyes were glued to the paper, even long after it was finished; I'd started to read it again. And again. And not so long after that, again. So far, I've read it a total of fifteen times.
I missed Hogwarts. This is not a negative thing, just something that I wished didn't happened, though I knew it was crucial to be so. I missed the Quidditch, interesting classes, and loads of homework assignments, dangerous spells, N.E.W.T. exams, and school secrets. It felt like I myself had missed my final year of Hogwarts along with Harry, and that was a year I had been looking forward to the most. Instead, he's out in a dark and dangerous world. This is not a bad plotline, just...a different one.
The characters mature and develop in amazing ways, and they're flawed to a lovable perfection that almost everybody can relate to. The dialogue is one of her greatest talents, I can easily imagine these characters speaking to each other in my head. I imagine them too often in fact, sometimes, they won't shut up. However, at the end, I felt like asking some characters... were have they been? What happened to Luna's parent's? Neville's grandmother? The remaining Death Eaters? Important information has been left out.
This book wasn't perfect, no, not at all. The death and loss in this book are shallow, and no real emotion was experienced when the characters died, especially Lupin, Tonks, and Fred near the book's end. The value of the loss isn't explored, making the reader forget more about what is missing, and making the whole tragedy almost cheesy. This is not realistic, and unless Harry is insensitive, then we're really missing something here.
Also, the epilogue was amateurish and thoroughly unsatisfying, and again, didn't include a ton of crucial information that J.K. Rowling only discussed in chat transcripts. The book would have been a lot better without it, and I felt like skipping over the almost insulting sentences and winced when I'd done that section.
Even though this book has it's flaws, nothing is perfect. In a way, I'm glad it has it's imperfections; I learn to be a better writer when reading them. If it was a beautifully written, flawless novel, I may have been too intimidated to write on my own. I just look past this book's bad parts, and focus on the good sections. When I read this book over, and over, and over, and over, the structure of the sentences jump out at me, and each time I read it, I look at this book in a different way every time. It's a highly entertaining adventure, and I look forward to reading it - again, in the future.
No matter how good this book was, nobody can deny what J.K. Rowling has created - an incredible, complex world of wizards and witches, one that seems too real to not be true. She inspired thousands - if not millions - of people, and encouraged a lot of young readers to learn, write, read, and think for themselves.
As I turned the final page of Harry Potter, sadness wells in my heart that there shall be no more, yet I'm deeply grateful to Ms. Rowling for the gift she has given us. The fascinating realm she created. The gift of real magic.