Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Great reference for people learning ActionScript - Review written on January 09, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
This book is a good reference for people learning ActionScript. It covers many advanced topics, and covers them well. As with most books, you will still have to apply yourself to take the concepts taught in this book and make them work in your project.
I have been a very strong Flash ActionScript programmer for many years. I have taught myself how to program by reading the ActionScript dictionary and other Flash manuals. What this means is that I know most of what Flash can do, but I have to apply myself to know how to combine that knowledge to create the result I want with my applications. Fortunately, I have a great aptitude for this.
Because of this background, I don't typically find many books covering topics I don't already know. Going into this review, I wrote down the expectations I had for this book.
1) teach me how to create and use Classes (a new concept for me)
2) be a language reference that I can use while developing projects
Classes are covered very early, which is refreshing. Since ActionScript is build around so many Classes, it's a good idea to cover creating your own Classes. The book covers creating Classes step-by-step, and walks through adding one feature at a time which makes it very easy to follow.
This book doesn't fulfill by second expectation however. I was expecting that this book would have every ActionScript command documented and give an explanation which would be more digestible than the ActionScript dictionary's. This book doesn't provide that, which isn't a bad thing; it just doesn't align with my expectations.
The book classifies the reader level at Beginning to Advanced... I don't agree with this. I would definitely recommend this book to someone who is already familiar with Flash, and wants to know more about ActionScript.
Finally - a book with meat! - Review written on December 07, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
If you're a hard-core developer with a background in "real" OOP (not "Object-Oriented-Like" scripting tools such as ActionScript, but rather languages such as C++, C# etc.), then this book is for you. Previously, I bought 3 other books on ActionScript (including "Training From The Source") trying to find one that didn't take the pansy "click here, drag that, type this" approach - I wanted a book that told me "WHY" I should do something and show me the code to do it - no pictures, please, just code. Without knowing why you're doing something, you have just relegated yourself to doing only what others have done before you - you will never go beyond that. This book gives you background on why things are the way they are, when it might change, and what to do in the meantime, and the pros and cons of each choice.
The only weakness I see is that it covers a lot of detail about progamming basics that take up pages needlessly for the more advanced developer. But you can always just skip those sections - those topics make the book more appealing to newbies. I myself did learn a lot about RegEx that I never knew before.
I'm sure this book has other shortcomings somewhere, but I can't see it yet because I'm too tickled to find one that talks directly to folks who don't hold that funky "timeline" thing as the Holy Grail.
+- - Review written on August 22, 2006
Rating: 3 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 3 did not.
The Book:
It's a bad example for the title it presents.
Actually, is not a full Bible. If you think you're buying this book thinking you get a reference bible for any kind of code problem, you're wrong. You have to read it all. Yep, from the start. This, if you want to know what's beeing talked about in chapters ahead.
To a medium Flash user, it's another good, not excellent, book.
To Amazon team:
And by the way, I found no complaint zone in the help links of amazon, so I have to say I'm disappointed with them, because my book, althought fully legible, came with a huge encadernation error.
Disappointed - Review written on June 08, 2006
Rating: 1 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 2 did not.
I generally believe the Wiley Computer Bible series is outstanding. The in-depth coverage of the various programs, excellent examples, and broad scope of information is tremendous. This book, however, is proving to be very disappointing. The coverage of topics is incomplete and many subjects are not even discussed. A significant omission is the data-related component category, which given the sparse documentation elsewhere, was a primary reason I purchased this book. I find myself reading the free Adobe Flash 8 PDF files instead of this book. Granted, I don't expect this book to rehash what's already available at Adobe's web site or in the help files, but I do expect a Wiley Bible book to provide a clear and thorough explanation of topics which augment and expand upon the program's free documentation, giving me valuable insight and examples. All in all, this book is proving to be a better door stop than a comprehensive and useful reference book.