Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Peak of Magic - Review written on May 19, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban (year 3 at Hogwarts) is regarded by some as the best book of the Harry Potter series. After recently re-reading the entire series, I think am ready to jump on the bandwagon.
For starters, this book has a very compelling plot, brilliantly crafted characters (most notably, Sirius Black) and a critically important plot twist towards the end which shapes the next several books of the series. It introduces the friends of Harry's father, all of whom have extremely important roles to play in the series. It creates a sense of danger, but still manages to be humorous and fun at the right times. And this is the last book in the series that manages to keep itself to a fairly low word count.
There are several key moments of humor (centering on the marauders and Dumbledore's offhand observations, for instance) and poignancy (Harry finding out the truth about the betrayal of his parents, conjuring of patronuses, and saving the lives of characters whose deaths would have been tragic). And this, of ALL of the books in the series, is the only one where I don't feel like the adults are improbably inept. The way in which Harry "solves" the mystery (or gets forcibly dragged to the solution!) is believable and unique to him, such that I can accept that none of the teachers would have solved it.
This story is important as it shows Harry starting to believe in his own abilities, and beginning to really take a stand for what he knows is right. He shows mercy and compassion, a sense of justice and conviction, and of course hope and love. In a way, this book has the "happiest" ending of any in the series, and certainly a meaningful one.
In short, is this the best book in the Harry Potter series? I can't say absolutely that it is, but I'm certainly having difficulty convincing myself that it's not.
Great plot -- I sped through it! - Review written on February 04, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
I'm finally getting around to reading the Harry Potter books. I've seen the movies that have come out thus far (well, except for Order of the Phoenix, which is on forever-wait-list at Netflix), so I have the picture of them in my head as I read. I would usually prefer the other way around (read, then watch), but I think the movies follow the books so nicely it doesn't really matter.
OK, but this is a review of the book, not the movie.
As with the first two books, Ms Rowling takes us on a wild ride of magic, odd characters, plot twists, and bending of the laws of physics. Her writing style makes you want to read one more chapter before putting the book down (indeed, I had to finish the last 200-some pages yesterday, despite the lateness of the hour). This really demonstrates her ability to tell a tale and is great for the main age group she's writing for -- if these books get kids as interested in reading as I am, they're worth their weight in galleons!
This book finds Harry preparing to start his third year at Hogwarts. As usual, he has to struggle with his non-wizard relatives, the Dursleys, as he gets ready to take the Hogwarts Express back to school. As in both of the first two books, there is a new Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher (much to Snape's chagrin, as he wants the job). Harry is happy to be back with his friends Ron and Hermione, even if Hermione is becoming an even bigger striver than she was last year (taking several classes in the same time slot?).
The driver of this plot, as the title suggests, is a prisoner (Sirius Black) who has escaped from Azkaban, a wizard prison from which escape was thought to be impossible. Harry overhears that Sirius has killed Harry's parents and is now after him. This leads to all the usual twists and turns, action, new creatures, revelations of characters' history that made the first two books so enjoyable.
What I liked: The story moves right along. Each book is building on the last, showing us more of the back story even as we move forward in time. Things are, once more, not always as they seem.
I have some minor complaints about comma splices, characters being written as all-good or all-bad (Snape is still my favorite character, as he has at least a little ambiguity around him), and the use of "lizard" -- a reptile -- as a synonym for "salamander" -- an amphibian. OK, they were magic salamanders, but I'm pretty sure the taxonomy should hold. It's like calling a dolphin a fish. Ms Rowling also telegraphs a lot in her writing, but maybe you have to think of the primary audience. For example, if you can't figure out at least some aspects of the deeper secrets of Prof Lupin and Sirius Black, you're not really paying attention (or you're not into etymology).
But gosh -- minor complaints, really. These books are fantastic. I'm already 150 pages into the next one!
Best of Potter - Review written on February 04, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
Of the first three Harry Potter books, I must say, this is the first where the nail was truly hit smack on the head, and I went "OMGSQUEE THAT WAS GOOD WHERE IS THE NEXT BOOK NOW?".
From start until finish, this is by far my favorite of the Potter books I have so far read. It's so... twisty. Spiraling back in on itself in more ways than one, and sometimes literally -- and actually changing how we see some of the characters already established. And I am such a fan of backstory -- getting a bit more knowledge of the past (especially, as here, in regard to Harry's parents) makes me quite happy indeed.
The plot's the best this far along in the series, and it's complex -- much moreso than either of the first two. It also has some of the neatest gadgets that J.K.R. has so far come up with; this one is such a page-turner.
Ms. Rowling's overall arc, as was predictable in the first few books, grows much more complex, and at many times, is so... touching. Touching and heartfelt -- you can't help but have empathy for so many of the characters.
Did I mention the nifty gadgets?
All in all, the plot and new characters make up for any other shortcomings. Don't start with this book, but definitely read it.
Best audiobook experience there is. - Review written on December 27, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
EDIT: Some people mark audio reviews as "unhelpful", which I found strange, until I realized what Amazon does.
-- They pool audio and text reviews and place all of those reviews on each of the products' pages, regardless of form the material is taking. You wouldn't expect a book review on the DVD's page. In this case, every word is the same, but a book review tells you only about the story, not the quality of the audio product.
-- But any regular audiobook listener has experienced a great book poorly read, or hammed up, or a voice that grated on your nerves, or found a book you loved to listen to, but couldn't find the time to sit and read (Lord of the Rings for me).
-- A review of the author's work tells you NOTHING about the audio, and yet, if you try and find what you're getting into, you have to sift through MANY book reviews before finding out the quality of the voice work, as most people have reviewed the author and the book, rather than the audiobook.
-- So, here's a small review of the audiobook, if you're interested in purchasing that. If you're looking for a review of the author, I am not being unhelpful, but Amazon is. I will request that they change their policy and display the reviews separately.
... Jim Dale is one of the best voice actors I've ever listened to and he brought the books to life an a way that reading could never do. I like reading, but it's really incredible to have someone put a different voice to every character, displaying the emotions and tone of the interactions.
... They are a really phenomenal experience, and I've listened to them over again and again.
Harry Potter and the Prisoner ("I am a man,not a number!") - Review written on October 25, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
"Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban" shows JK Rowling still in her prime. Harry,in his anger,practices magic in the Muggle world...instead of being punished by the Ministry of Magic,he must be sequestered in the tavern called the Leaky Cauldron. He learns that Sirius Black, a notorious serial killer and escaped fugitive from the wizarding prison of Azkaban, is after him. Harry learns about the Animagi, wizards capable of changing their form into those of animals, and of his protective spirit, the Patronus. Hermione shows she has the ability to "turn back time" with her Time Turner...thus able to take plenty of classes,and in the end,save the day.
"The Prisoner of Azkaban" is probably the most moving of the Harry Potter series as Harry learns the truth about himself and himself. He learns about prejudice from his new Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher,Remus Lupin,who faces discrimination because hes a werewolf. The fact that his father,James,had the ability to turn into a stag recalls the ancient legend of St.Patrick turning himself into a stag to escape murderous Druids. "Prisoner of Azkaban" has an intricate,engaging plot and brilliant characterization. Could JK Rowling hold onto her winning streak?