Amazon.com Customer Reviews
A real disappointment - Review written on July 12, 2008
Rating: 2 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
Most popular fiction doesn't hold my interest anymore. All too often, the writing is too bland and unimaginative, the plots are standard fare, and the characters are one-dimensional. Tess Gerritsen is one of the few thriller writers whose work I've enjoyed in recent years. Her writing isn't that special, but she does have real storytelling skill, so that her books have always kept me reading.
The first two books featuring Jane Rizzoli, THE SURGEON and THE APPRENTICE, were truly suspenseful. Rizzoli is close to being a believable character, with the kind of problems that most of us can identify with. In the third novel, THE SINNER, Rizzoli moved to backup status, to make way for the pathologist Dr. Maura Isles. Unfortunately, Isles has yet to become a realistic character. She is more of a placeholder, an inert viewpoint character who exists simply as a device to hang the plot on.
And that's a real problem with BODY DOUBLE. The story has much of the gruesome fascination of THE SURGEON and THE APPRENTICE, and yet it lacks tension. It's fitfully suspenseful, but I got through 150 pages and felt like I was waiting for the story to get started. Over halfway through the book, I still felt that way, and came close to setting it aside for something more interesting.
I finally started skimming, and it finally got interesting again towards the end. However, most of the mystery is unraveled about 50 pages before the story finally concludes, so the rest of the book feels like a long epilogue.
For me, this was just a badly built plot, one that fails to build tension and only delivers sporadically. Far from being the kind of riveting read I was expecting, BODY DOUBLE was a book which thrilled me mostly when I was done with it, and could read something else.
I'll probably try the next book in the series (since I already bought it) but I'm surprised at how highly rated this one is. I hope VANISH sees a return to form.
Very Good! - Review written on June 23, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
This is the fourth book in the Patholigist Dr. Maura Isles/Detective Jane Rizzoli series, and stands up pretty well in comparision with the other three novels.
In this one, Dr. Maura Isles has to go deep into her past, and find hidden, shocking truths, about her family in order to solve a modern day crime.
As always, the characters of Maura Isles and Jane Rizzoli are engaging, and the plot in this book had quite a few twists in it, too. There was frequently something new being discovered, or an event happening, in the storyline, that would make you want to read on further.
Gerritsen always pleases--and chills! - Review written on June 10, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
Body Double is Gerritsen's fourth novel in the Detective Jane Rizzoli series of medical thrillers. She interweaves her main plot, discovering the murderer of her main character's (Dr. Maura Isles) adopted twin sister, with several subplots, including locating her birth mother, the pain of a frustrating romance, the death of another lover, all intermingled with personal death threats. Her series hero Jane Rizzoli is in the last trimester of her pregnancy, which adds another layer of apprehension to the novel, in that the suspected murderer is involved in human trafficking, namely selling babies stolen from their mother's womb. The story has very little "down time," and Gerritsen does a first-rate job of building tension throughout the book.
An Old Twist Well-Played - Review written on September 01, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
I've been told that you can give an artist the most hackneyed, the most overused, and the most simple idea and they can make something new of it that's worth looking at. I don't know that everyone can do that, but there are a select few that can.
Most writers are told there are only a handful of plots in the world. Literary professors seem convinced that every plot that has ever come out in American novels can be found within Mark Twain's HUCKLEBERRY FINN. I'm not going to disagree with that assessment, but I am going to doubt it a little.
One thing for certain, Tess Gerritsen's fourth Boston Police Department Homicide Detective Jane Rizzoli novel at first appears to be a writer in search of a plot. Medical Examiner Maura Isles came to the forefront of the last novel, THE SINNER, and she remains the focus of this one.
The idea of a "mysterious twin" or "dark twin" is one of the oldest plot tricks in the book. Mark Twain performed his magic on the plot device in THE PRINCE AND THE PAUPER. Before that Alexandre Dumas did it with THE MAN IN THE IRON MASK and Anthony Hope used it in THE PRISONER OF ZENDA.
Just as these other masters of fiction pulled successful rabbits out of their hats, Gerritsen does the same with Dr. Maura Isles and her murdered twin. During the course of this novel, Jane Rizzoli is sidelined to degree while in her eighth month of pregnancy. Her relationship with FBI Special Agent Gabriel Dean continues to grow and this one, although they have problems back and forth.
Isles's provocative relationship with Father Daniel Brophy (barely touched on in THE SINNER) looms larger in the series as both Isles and Brophy have to fight against temptation and old feelings that haven't gone away.
The story opens in a gripping fashion with Isles arriving back at her house after a forensic conference in France. Police cars and Rizzoli are already at her address. When Rizzoli reveals the dead woman, Isles is blown away. The woman looks just like her.
Enough to be her twin.
In fact, subsequent forensic investigation reveals that the dead woman has to be Isles's plan. Their blood work and even their DNA matches. Isles was raised as an adopted child and had no clue that she had a blood family, much less an identical twin.
After digging into the dead woman's background, Isles and Rizzoli discover that sheet - like Isles - was adopted. In fact, the same lawyer attended to the placement of both children.
Driven by her need to know who she really is and who her family was - not out of curiosity, but out of self-preservation - Isles begins the painful search for her true roots. The trail is twisted and filled with a lot of unpleasant surprises. More than that, Rizzoli becomes convinced that Isles is tracking a serial killer whose work fantasies involve killing pregnant women - which makes Rizzoli a prime target.
BODY DOUBLE is a compelling experience that drags the readers through the pages at a frantic gallop. Although some of the plot at times feels familiar, Gerritsen brings so much to it that is new. This novel is definitely one of the most tense of the series and delivers a slambang ending.
Gerritsen's newest novel, THE BONE GARDEN, is a stand-alone and not a Rizzoli and Isles book. However, from the description it sounds like a roller-coaster ride waiting to happen. Unfortunately, fans of Rizzoli and Isles are going to have to wait at least one more year for another tale.
This book kept me reading! - Review written on April 15, 2006
Rating: 4 out of 5
Now, I have been reading quite a bit of Tess's books and I must say i found this one an ABSOLUTE enjoyment.
the first chapter was such an attention grabber that it gave me the creaps that it facinates me to think how does she think up of these things!
Dr. Maura after getting back home from a tiring flight from paris gets shocked into the crowd and the police cars that were swarming in front of her house. not knowing what is going on she get out of the cab that she was at and approaches the sceen just to have everyone look at her like they seen a GHOST! and literally they have every reason to be.
in front of her house, parked in a simple car was a woman who has been shot, she was the splitting image of dr. maura her self! making this book so interesting, it was hard to put it down. this suddenly was a personal call for dr. maura to find out who the woman was, why does she look like her so much, what does the mysterious woman do for a living, and who her real parents are! to the light romance she was having or felt like she was having, with a man/cop who known who the woman was, her sister.
i can not express how happy i was to pick up this book, if i said anymore then i would be giving almost the whole book away. all i can say is that you will absolutely not know who the killer is until the very end! the way she ties all the murders together was ingenious! omg i almost gave out a spoiler.
guys i highly recommend this book to read!
A nail biter with some literary depth! - Review written on March 24, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
Boston medical examiner, Dr Maura Isles, returns home from a working vacation at a forensic pathology conference and is shocked to discover that her home is a murder crime scene with herself starring in the role of victim. Chaos and confusion reign until consultation with detective Jane Rizzoli and further investigation reveal that the victim, Maura Isles' doppelgänger, not only shares her blood type and birth date but, based on DNA investigation, is actually an identical twin. The questions are deliciously obvious to the investigators and the reader alike - who was the actual intended victim, Dr Isles or her hitherto unknown sister?; if it was Dr Isles, then why did her unknown twin come onto the scene at that precise moment; if it was her sister, then what was she doing parked in Dr Isles' driveway?; who was their mother and why was Dr Isles unaware that she had a twin sister? I won't waste any further ink on plot synopsis because, frankly, nothing further need be said. Nobody could possibly put "Body Double" down once they've read, oh, maybe three or four paragraphs!
There can be no denying it - Gerritsen is an extraordinarily skilled artist of the realism school when it comes to painting a thriller canvas! She brushes a background completed with broad daring strokes but, at the same time, completes a foreground with attention to the most meticulous detail. "Body Double" succeeds on any number of fronts. Rather than dwelling purely on a summary of a plot, as exciting as it is, of course, it's more worthwhile spending a little time on the enjoyable successes that set Body Double apart from more run-of-the-mill thrillers.
Body Double provides an eerie, realistic chronicle of the development of a psychopathic serial murderer.
We are treated to superb examples of the use of modern police investigation techniques including, of course, forensic pathology and computer analysis.
Readers are forced to ask themselves difficult philosophical questions relating to adoption: To what extent do adoptees have a right to their natural history? To what extent do mothers giving up their children for adoption have the right to confidentiality? Nature or nurture? What is the prime determinant of personality, intelligence and skill make-up of adopted children? (Now here's a real toughie for you ... if you were an adopted child and you came into the certain knowledge that your mother was a schizophrenic and a convicted criminal, how would you feel about that and would you feel the compulsion to visit and learn more about her?)
Her story also forces us to ask ourselves what we might do faced with unresolvable, impossible "urges" - in this case, a sexual attraction to a priest who is clearly aware of the attraction and yet is absolutely committed to his vocation!
Today, we are well acquainted with serial killers such as Paul Bernardo, for example, whose name alone in Ontario is sufficient to conjure up a case of shivers. In Body Double, Gerritsen has given us a moment of respite by creating a victim who somehow found the inner strength to resist and confound her stalker, torturer and would-be murderer! (The ending of this little sub-plot will make you want to stand up and cheer at the same time as your laughing yourself silly!)
What do you think? Have I said enough to convince you that Body Double is a five-star thriller must read?
Paul Weiss
Like crime drama on network TV - Review written on December 28, 2005
Rating: 3 out of 5
If you like "CSI" or "Bones" this book might be a pleasant diversion. I don't read crime drama often, but this book was enteraining in that vein. It's the sort of book a person can whip through in a short time.
The reason I rated it so low is that the characters weren't really that believable. Maura, the heroine, at one point was eating lobster takeout in Maine, and was telling her companion that she had never eaten lobster in the shell before. Her explanation was that she had just moved to Boston from San Francisco. I found myself thinking, "Huh? How can a grown person live in both San Francisco and Boston and be eating lobster in the shell for the first time?" These types of little details made it harder to suspend disbelief and were distracting. (Maybe that's just me.)
Also, as another reviewer mentions, the author misses some opportunities to explore the characters of the villains. She seems to spend more time describing the perverse character of a psychologist who is fascinated by murderers than on the murderers.
At one twist in the plot, the character involved was so obscure I had to leaf back through the book to job my memory.
I would have enjoyed the book more if it had a bit more character development in the key players of the plot, or if all of the better developed characters played more interesting roles in the plot twists. Actually both would have been good.
However, since the other books by this author review well, and since I secretly enjoy crime fiction, sign me up for the next one!