Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Superlative - Review written on July 26, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
i first read these books as a complete set when working in a refugee camp in thailand. they blew my mind then as had done the reading to me of the voyage of the dawn treader as a young boy at bording school. i love these books they are most special, but dont come up to the level of lord of the rings... in my opinion. still, i reckon second only to lord of the rings and never ending story otherwise none other fantasy fiction can meet this standard.
in the lion, the witch and the wardrobe (the second narnia book) the children enter into narnia, emboundened with ice, narnia is a hard and cold place to live, through the devices of the witch. in the vendidad of the zend avesta (zoroastrian scripture) yima is warned by Ahura Mazda, the one most high and only true god warns him of an upcoming catastrophe: "O fair Yima, son of Viva..hat! Upon the material world the evil winters are about to fall, that shall bring the fierce, deadly frost; upon the material world the evil winters are about to fall, that shall make snow-flakes fall thick, even an ardvi deep on the highest tops of mountains." it is in winter that snow-flakes fall, and only from a grey sky. but lets pray God almighty that we be spared from such a dreadful time ahead... and pray for peace, but without oppression, "nevertheless father, not as i will, but as thou wilt". we should do well to remember jesus's prayer in the garden of gethsemane before his crucifixion. shortly afterward he was betrayed by a kiss.
with love, from, snow-flake. xxx
More wonderful than I expected! - Review written on July 13, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
Once I started reading the first of the seven books, I COULD NOT stop reading! As I finished each book, I couldn't wait to get to the next one. There's something spellbinding about C.S. Lewis's work, and I firmly believe that it's because it was God-inspired.
I've never been one who enjoyed reading books about centaurs, fauns, and other mythological creatures; but this amazing Christian allegory kept my attention from start to finish!
The only thing I regret about reading this series is that I waited until I retired from a career as a public school teacher to read it! It makes me sad to think of the vast number of students that I could have encouraged to read it.
This, in my opinion, is a must-read for anyone who sees God as a judgmental, harsh, punishing Being. I believe that reading these seven books in the allegorical sense will help that person gain a greater understanding of the all-encompassing love that God shows for his children through Jesus Christ.
May Aslan and all of the other allegorical characters continue to instruct, entertain, and inspire readers of all ages for many decades to come!
A True Must Have! - Review written on May 23, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
These seven books are books that any fan of fantasy literature must have. I read these books when I was a child, again as a teen and once more as an adult. I look forward to reading them again and again because I always find something new in the pages.
I have also enjoyed the first two Narnia movies. The BBC made movies out of four of these books, but they did not have the same computer animation technology that we have now, so they may seem somewhat dated. Anyway, back to the books...
My only problem with the boxed sets and the individual books as they have been repackaged and sold is that they are no longer in the order that C.S. Lewis wrote them in. I have to believe that he wrote the books in a particular order for a reason, so we ought to read them in that order. The original order (and the order of my original boxed set) is as follows: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, Prince Caspian, The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, The Silver Chair, The Horse and His Boy, The Magician's Nephew, and The Last Battle. Chronologically from the founding of Narnia, the books run thus: Magician's Nephew, Lion Witch Wardrobe, Horse and His Boy, Prince Caspian, Silver Chair, Last Battle. I strongly suggest that you read them in the order they were written.
"0 of 1,532,654 people found this review helpful..." - Review written on May 14, 2008
Rating: 1 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful, 48 did not.
The Chronicles of Narnia are highly regarded as, more or less, the apex of modern fantasy. But I beg to differ. In fact, this is some of the worst writing I have ever read.
First off, let me address the book's religious content. I am not religious, but I have no issue with people who are, as long as they don't force their religion to become mine. C.S. Lewis is the kind of person who DOES force his religion to be yours, and I've got issues with that. And he does so in the most didactic, egotistical way possible: by, in essence, rewriting the Bible.
Seriously. The Magician's Nephew IS the Book of Genesis. The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe IS the death and resurrection of Christ. The Horse and His Boy (more or less, I'll admit this is a bit of a stretch, but it does involve extended wanderings in the desert to a sacred place) IS Exodus, and is also an appalingly racist creation. Apparently Lewis saw that there was nothing immoral or anything about patronizing anyone who wasn't white. Prince Caspian IS a boring, ponderous book that I never even finished, it was so bad. And I generally like to read books from beginning to end. The Voyage of the Dawn Treader IS Paul's the Apostles' travels across the world after Jesus ascended into Heaven. The Silver Chair is heavily (a-HEM)indebted to the temptation of Eve. And The Last Battle is the most see-through apocalypse metaphor I can name you.
So not only does Lewis have the nerve to blatantly rewrite one of the bases of western theology, he also does so in the most smug, irritating manner. Even Tolkein, a friend of his and a far superior writer, was dismissive of these books, aptly labeling them as condescending. I'd add "ponderous" - seriously, Prince Caspian was a painful read, with Lewis dwelling on and exaggerating the most mundane of details.
And then there's the discrimination. I've already mentioned the racism, but there are sexist elements, too. The character Susan, a teenager, discovers sex and is excluded from Narnia as such. Never mind that she is at such an age when everyone (including, it can be assumed, Mr. Lewis himself) discovers sex. It's just a natural part of the maturation process, and is not something to be feared. But Lewis treats it in the most appalling way possible, by dismissing a character in his story because she's going through a process anyone would. This is doubly detrimental to my enjoyment of the book - not only is it prudish, it's also sexist, since it so happens that Susan is, obviously, a girl.
And here's the central part of what I don't like about this book - Lewis is simply a bad writer. None of the characters have any appeal to me. None of the settings have any appeal to me. The dialog is stiff, unnatural, awkward, and dry.
Look, if I wanted to read the Bible, I'd read the Bible. If I wanted a slow, boring, didactic lecture on how the ONLY way to lead a good life is by being a fundamentalist Christian... well, I don't want one of those, and if anyone sends me a comment on this containing that I will simply ignore it. And I CERTAINLY wouldn't read these books. If I wanted good fantasy, I'd read either The Lord of the Rings or Harry Potter (by the way, J.K. Rowling also is disdainful of these books, and like Tolkien she's got much more talent than Lewis). This isn't even "train wreck" bad, it's just your average lousy book series. I don't know, maybe my staunch agnostic beliefs (if such a thing is even possible) contributes to my intense dislike of this dreary series, but it just doesn't do it for me.