I got my cube in 03 and quickly purchased the 03 version, obviously. Excellent football sim, best I had played to that point. Then got 04, which was basically the same but better. I then got 05 the next year and was very depressed at how much worse it had gotten as far as game play and graphics - more Maddenish which to me is worse - lack of control over the player is the best way I can describe it. Well its now going into the 2008 era and yeah I'm still playing this game, thats how perfect it is. Perfect graphics, perfect control, perfect dynasty mode, way better than 05, they must have changed programmers or something after this one.

THIS GAME IS AWESOME EXCEPT FOR ONE THING THE COMMENTATORS!
THEY GO LIKE TIME TO GET THE NEW QB IN THERE USC YOUR QB HAS THROWN A RECORD 10 INTERCEPTIONS. AND I AM BEING
USC SO I SAY BACK TO THT COMMENTATOR TIME FOR YOU TO SHUT UP
COMMENTATOR YOU HAVE BEEN YAPPING FOR A RECORD 100 YEARS.
OVERALL SOUND A+
COMMENTARY F- (EXCEPT FOR BEGINNING OF GAME)
GRAPHICS A-
GAMEPLAY B+
DYNASTY MODE A+
OVERALL B+
TEXAS LONGHORNS SUCK! USC SHOULD HAVE WON ROSE BOWL IF REF HADN'T MADE SUCH A BAD CALL DID YOU SEE VINCE YOUNG ON HIS KNEES AND THAN HE PASSED FOR A TD! GOOOOTTRRROOOJJJANNNNSS TEXAS SUCKS! TEXAS SUCKS! USC TROJANS ROCK! USC TROJANS ROCK! USC TROJANS ROCK! USC IS BETTER THAN TEXAS!

I enjoy college football, so for me, this game is a blast to play.

When I popped this game into my gamecube, I was amazed by the graphcis (NCAA Football: 2004 was my first Gamecube game). In fact, the graphics are so awesome, that my grandparents thought it was a real football game (wow). But, graphics arn't everything. This game is incredabally fun, and has dramitically increased my knowlage of football. Even you don't have a memorycard, you can play the majority of this game, making it well worth the price.

Man, this game is awesome. I first got it a while after it came out mainly for the lower price, and was bummed out i hadn't got it sooner. It's not like the rosters are different, because they dont have any names, which is one aspect that made this a four out of five. Here are some attributes for the game;
Gameplay- A
Graphics- A+
Features- A
Realism- B
Overall- A
The Gameplay is pretty good, mainly because of the graphics, which lead me too the graphics. I gave it an A+ because of the fine facial and uniform detail. As you might see, the tackles and celebratons are pretty similar to Madden, but that's not a bad thing. I loved the mascot and cheerleader sequences, and the option of some games being telivised and others not. The features are great, becuase of the re-living classic games thing, and all that other stuff. In dynasty mode, you can do alot of stuff, from drafting high schoolers to hanging on as head coach. Trust me, it's late at night right now and i'm tired, so i've forgotten the majority of the things you can do. The realism is a tad fakey, like the constant injury of players and Washington beating #1 ohio state. (that was in the first week of my dynasty)
One thing i relly didnt expect was the overflowing amounats of fight songs, and how good they sound. I swear, i had the notre dame song in my head ALL DAY.
Overall, this game is great, even beyond great, but i do suggest you research your favorite team and name the rosters. when the commentators say it, it just gives you that important feeling. Well i gotta go play, did i mention this game is extremely addictive?