Handel - Messiah / Erickson, McNair, Hodgson, Humphrey, Stilwell, Atlanta SO, Shaw

by Telarc

$17.98
buy from amazon.com
Average Rating: * * * * -
Sales Rank:6321 (lower is better)
Price Used:$4.00
Shipping:Free Shipping on most orders over $25*
Availability:Usually ships in 24 hours
Release Date:1990-10-25
Label:Telarc
UPC:089408009327
Binding:Audio CD
Published By:Telarc
ASIN:B000003CT7
Category:Music

Tracks on Handel - Messiah / Erickson, McNair, Hodgson, Humphrey, Stilwell, Atlanta SO, Shaw by Telarc

  1. Sinfonia
  2. 2. Comfort Ye, My People/3. Every Valley Shall Be Exalted
  3. 4. And The Glory Of The Lord
  4. 5. Thus Saith The Lord/6. But Who May Abide /7. And He Shall Purify
  5. 8. Behold, A Virgin Shall Conceive/9. O Thou That Tellest Good Tidings To Zion
  6. Messiah: Part One: 10. For Behold, Darkness Shall Cover The Earth - Bass Recitative; 11. The People That Walked In Darkness - Bass Air
  7. 12. For Unto Us A Child Is Born
  8. 13. Pifa - 'Pastoral Symphony'/14a. There Were Shepherds/14b. And Lo, The Angel Of The Lord Came Upon Them/15. And The Angel Said Unto Them/16. And Suddenly There Was With The Angel/17. Glory To God
  9. 18. Rejoice Greatly, O Daughter Of Zion
  10. 19. Then Shall The Eyes Of The Blind
  11. 20. He Shall Feed His Flock Like A Shepherd
  12. 21. His Yoke Is Easy
  13. 22. Behold The Lamb Of God
  14. 23. He Was Despised
  15. 24. Surely He Hath Borne Our Griefs
  16. 25. And With His Stripes We Are Healed/26. All We Like Sheep
  17. 27. All They That See Him/28. He Trusted In God
  18. 29. Thy Rebuke Hath Broken His Heart/30. Behold, And See If There Be Any Sorrow/31. He Was Cut Off Out Of The Land Of The Living/32. But Thou Didst Not Leave
  19. 33. Lift Up Your Heads
  20. 34. Unto Which Of The Angels/35. Let All The Angels Of God Worship Him
  21. 36. Thou Art Gone Up On High
  22. 37. The Lord Gave The Word
  23. 38. How Beautiful Are The Feet
  24. 39. Their Sound Is Gone Out
  25. 40. Why Do The Nations?/41. Let Us Break Their Bonds Asunder
  26. 42. He That Dwelleth In Heaven/43. Thou Shalt Break Them
  27. 44. Hallelujah
  28. 45. I Know That My Redeemer Liveth
  29. 46. Since By Man Came Death
  30. 47. Behold, I Tell You A Mystery/48. The Trumpet Shall Sound
  31. 49. Then Shall Be Brought To Pass/50. O Death, Where Is Thy Sting?/51. But Thanks Be To God
  32. 52. If God Be For Us
  33. 53. Worthy Is The Lamb...Amen.

Customer Reviews

New vs. Old Shaw Recording - Reviewed on 2007-11-12
* * * *

I guess I am spoiled, but I truly like the older Shaw recording of Messiah better than the new one, and I have both of them. To me, these two stand light years above and beyond any other recordings on the market. I had the privilege of hearing in concert in person the Shaw Chorale present the earlier recording of Messiah, and have loved it since the mid 60s. The phrasings, entrances, tempi, diction have, in my opinion never been cleaner, crisper, or equaled, nor will they ever be--on BOTH recordings. In addition, on the later recoring he used only the ASO CHAMBER chorus, a smaller group within the full ASO chorus. He followed Handel's intentions, both in terms of numbers of singers and instrumentalists for both recordings, allowing for different personnel in the different performances that occurred during Handel's lifetime. Thankfully, BMG, formerly RCA, has finally released the older recording, which Mr. Shaw took at a faster tempo generally, and, based on his own comments in the booklet accompanying the 3 LP set, that older recording was based insofar as possible on the 1752-53 version of the work. He used the Watkins Shaw edition of the score (published by the British house of Novello), and the joy of the work literally shines through--on both recordings. You can't go wrong either way; I just happen to like the older recording better. I thank God I had the privilege of singing under him in the Brahms' Requiem in German less than a year before his death. Messiah and the Brahms--What a combination.!!
Inspiring rendition - Reviewed on 2007-11-01
* * * * *

I'm a Handel fan, but this particular recording ranks with my favorites. The instrumentation and chorals are vivid, and some memorable, excluding the more familiar sections you see in CD collections at the public library. So fortunate to have such quality in one version; complete!
Very Good Performance, Merely Good Sound - Reviewed on 2007-07-18
* * * *

As others have pointed out, the performance is, typically of Shaw, very good. But I've always wished for clearer sound. But I also realize that this is 1984 digital sound - even for Telarc.I guess there aren't too many audiophiles out there, judging from the number who give the sound an "excellent" rating!
Recommended, nonetheless.
Woohoo! - Reviewed on 2006-08-16
* * * * *
3 customers found this review helpful.

I love this! This is the best "Messiah" recording ever made. I listen to it every day(literally).
Absolutely Awesome! - Reviewed on 2006-01-19
* * * * *
3 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.

This recording is one of my favorite CDs. And I am disappointed that some reviewers do not care for it. The late Robert Shaw is known as the greatest conductor in America. This said, I find it funny that some reviewers think they know more than he does.

Diction is excellent. And the sound is typical Shaw: spine-tingling. Choral music and Handel lovers should DEFINITELY buy this CD. With Robert Shaw, you are always in for a treat. Trust his musical knowledge, sit back, and enjoy a great (if not the best) recording of Messiah.
Read More Customer Reviews »
Go To Amazon Product Page

* - See Amazon Product Page for shipping and pricing details.


Book Subjects